'Of course she asked about warnings,' Mrs Fenwick said. 'She always wanted to know who had been told and who had not.'
The observation unsettled him. It could have belonged to any bright child, yet he had spent years keeping his own questions about warnings and records shut in a box. He asked whether the teacher remembered any other detail. She said Iris sometimes spoke about wanting to become a builder because builders decided where doors went. The statement was followed, in the teacher's memory, by a disagreement with another pupil who wanted to become a magician and believed magic could move houses more efficiently. Mrs Fenwick laughed at the memory, then apologised for laughing. Damian told her not to. For years he had heard almost nothing about Iris that was not immediately followed by an expression of sympathy. The ordinary absurdity of the argument felt like the return of a language he had nearly lost.
They drank tea while the florist below received a delivery. Mrs Fenwick asked cautiously what Damian expected from reopening the records. He told her about the photograph, the shelter and the hospital. He did not tell her that he had begun imagining a young woman in every passing face. She listened without widening her eyes or deciding how the story should end. When he finished, she told him she would look for the original class register and any copies of the bus photograph. She asked him to write the dates down. He did, and for a moment felt like the parent who had once been asked to sign a permission slip.
On the way home he bought a small pot of basil from the florist. He could not explain why. The plant sat on the windowsill beside the sink, where Iris had once grown beans. Every few days he watered it. The basil grew unevenly, leaning toward the light, and the leaves released a sharp scent when he brushed them. It was not a sign. It was not an answer. It was simply one living thing in a house where he had begun, hesitantly, to make room for a future he could not foresee.
The following Tuesday a copy of the newsletter arrived in the post. Mrs Fenwick had included a short note saying she was sorry she could not find the register but had found another drawing in which Iris had invented an emergency vehicle shaped like a tortoise. It carried a ladder, a whistle and a box labelled biscuits. Damian pinned the drawing above his desk. On some days the drawing made him ache with the knowledge that she had been clever at seven; on other days it made him laugh. He allowed both reactions. He did not ask the drawing to tell him whether she was alive.
Jo asked for the exact date from Ruth's photograph. Damian read it aloud, then read the spelling of the hospital a second time. Jo paused. There had been changes of name and administration since the floods, she said, and the old ward logs were not indexed the way current files were. He would need to submit the enquiry in writing and include documentary evidence of his relationship to Iris. She could send a form and explain the review procedure. He thanked her and wrote down the reference number on a shopping receipt. By the time they ended the call he had not discovered whether his daughter was alive. He had discovered that the first useful task required him to turn a question he could scarcely speak into a document another person could examine.
He made tea, forgot it and started a list. The first item was Ruth's envelope, which he had promised to collect at the café. The second was the old family file. The third was a call to Martin, who had sat with him during the original search and might remember what Damian could not. He looked at the list for several minutes. One item involved a stranger, one involved the worst week of his life, and one involved asking a friend to enter it again. He chose the stranger first, not because it mattered most, but because he had already agreed to meet her.
At the café, Ruth's little girl was sorting picture books into a precarious tower. The rabbit occupied a chair with its repaired ear pointed toward the window. Ruth had brought the envelope inside a plastic folder, the sort used for school notices. She put it down without sliding it across the table immediately. Her sister had given permission for the copies to be examined, she said, but wanted the original returned. Damian agreed. He had brought an empty folder of his own and a pencil, because he had begun to distrust the certainty of his memory. Ruth showed him the flap of the envelope and the marks where something had once been written and rubbed away. On the back of the photograph was the date, the hospital name and the words ‘girl in blue coat?’ with a question mark that looked more like a hook.
‘My sister wrote the question mark on purpose,’ Ruth said. ‘She was never saying she knew.’
‘I understand.’
‘Do you? Because I worry what this is going to do to you.’