When Ella saw Damian looking sad, she stopped beside him with her stuffed rabbit and offered him a kiss. Then she pointed toward the pictures on the mantel, and he told her he had lost his daughter ten years ago

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He apologised and asked for a copy of the duplicate sheet instead. Denise made one. She also showed him a memo written two months after the flood, explaining that passenger numbers had been estimated when buses stopped at several pick-up points. The memo was not evidence of deceit; it was evidence that the figures had never been as exact as the later reports implied. Damian had read official summaries stating that a particular number of people were transferred. He had assumed the number came from a headcount taken at a single door. Now he understood how an estimate could move from one document to another until it looked permanent.

They went into the garden after the paperwork had been put away. Denise had a small greenhouse, its glass panels clouded by condensation. She was growing winter lettuce in trays. Damian asked about the plants because he needed a conversation in which neither of them was required to talk about missing children. Denise showed him how she moved the trays when the temperature dropped and complained about slugs with a relish that made him smile. He told her about the basil plant in his kitchen. She advised him not to overwater it. He made a note on his phone, then laughed at himself for recording horticultural advice beside evidence about a bus.

Before he left Denise said she hoped the investigation would find something useful, but she warned him not to confuse a longer paper trail with a clearer answer. There were occasions when finding more documents revealed only how complicated the process had been. Damian acknowledged the warning. In the train station he looked at the copy of the bus record, then put it away and bought a newspaper. He read an article about the renovation of an old theatre without absorbing much of it. Yet he had made a decision he could live with: he would not contact the driver's family until the caseworker advised that it was necessary and appropriate.

“Ruth warned me I might have remembered a different child,” she said.

“I'm glad she did.”

“I'd rather you hear the bad parts as well as the hopeful ones.”

She led him through her recollection slowly. In the temporary shelter she had been assigned to photograph donated equipment and record shortages. A child had arrived from a roadside collection point, wrapped in a coat too large for her. Celia remembered the girl because she refused a sweet and asked twice for a blue notebook. She remembered a tiny scrape on one knee. She was less certain of the face. So many children had come through in wet coats, shaking or silent, and her memory had been altered by all the photographs she had studied afterward.

“A blue notebook?” Damian said.

“I think so. Something blue. I put it in my notes before I saw any missing notice.”

Iris had a blue notebook with drawings of invented animals. Damian had searched for it after her death and never found it. His throat tightened so abruptly that he asked for a glass of water.

Celia returned with the water and a photocopy of her original log. In the entry written that same day she had listed ‘small girl, dark hair, looks seven, blue book requested, transferred with nurse G.’ The note existed before she knew Iris's name. It was not proof, but it was not a memory invented this week either.

“Who was Nurse G?”

Celia's old photographs occupied three shoe boxes in her sister's attic. She had put them away after the relief committee dissolved, partly because she had moved house and partly because she could no longer bear to see images of people whose names she had never learned. Ruth helped her carry the boxes downstairs on a grey Sunday morning. The child was with a neighbour, and the house had the temporary quiet that comes when a family has made arrangements for difficult work. They spread a clean cloth across the table and sorted the photographs by envelope, trying not to rearrange anything until each group had been recorded.

Celia remembered the camera. It was a small silver model that used batteries she always forgot to replace. She had kept a roll of adhesive labels in her pocket and stuck a number on each envelope after developing the pictures. Several labels had peeled away. Some had been reused because money and supplies were scarce. The photographs showed cots, donated coats, a line of wet shoes outside a hall and a kitchen where three women were cutting bread. There were faces too, but Celia had deliberately avoided photographing people when they were distressed. She had wanted to document shortages, not turn private suffering into evidence of her own usefulness.

Ruth found a photograph of a low table beneath a clock. On the table stood a mug with a chipped handle and two sealed packets of crackers. The edge of a coat was visible near the frame. Celia studied it for a long time. She thought the corner might belong to the room where she had spoken with the unidentified girl. The coat looked dark in the photograph, perhaps because it was wet. Damian's daughter's coat had been yellow. Ruth reminded her that the child Celia remembered had been wrapped in a larger coat that belonged to someone else. Celia nodded. It was possible to construct a consistent explanation, but consistency was not proof.

News in the same category

When Ella saw Damian looking sad, she stopped beside him with her stuffed rabbit and offered him a kiss. Then she pointed toward the pictures on the mantel, and he told her he had lost his daughter ten years ago

45 Part