He had expected a professional to tell him either that hope was justified or that hope was dangerous. Esther offered neither. She asked him whether he had a way to speak to someone if the search produced a result he did not want. He said Martin. She asked whether Martin knew he had been chosen for that role. Damian promised to ask him. On his way home he telephoned his brother and discovered that Martin was standing in a queue at the hardware store. When Damian explained, there was a pause. Then Martin said yes, of course, though he would like to be told the appointments in advance so he could arrange his shifts. Damian laughed unexpectedly. His brother could turn even an extraordinary request into a matter of calendars and transport.
A week later the first formal reply arrived. It acknowledged the request but provided no substantive answer. Damian sat down at his kitchen table and felt the old urge to telephone someone and demand that the words mean more. He opened Esther's notes instead. An acknowledgment, she had written, was an acknowledgment. He made a small mark beside the date and left the rest of the page blank. The discipline was not comforting. It was still useful.
“Can I use your notes when I write to the hospital?”
“Yes. You can say exactly what I saw and what I didn't.”
He promised he would.
Over the following week the investigation became less like a revelation and more like work. Damian made phone calls before breakfast and copied documents in the afternoon. He created a timeline whose blanks disturbed him more than its entries. He contacted a solicitor named Esther Moore, recommended by a friend who had worked on missing-person cases. She listened without telling him either to believe or abandon the lead.
“The certificate is a legal record,” Esther said. “It doesn't become false because a new story sounds plausible. If there was a misidentification, we need admissible evidence to establish it. Also, if a surviving child is now an adult, her privacy matters. We can't treat her life as a file we're entitled to open.”
“I know.”
“You may know in principle. It becomes harder if the evidence points to somebody who doesn't want to be found.”
Damian looked at the folder. “I want to know whether I buried my daughter.”
“That is a fair question,” she said. “Let's find out what the records can establish before deciding whose name belongs where.”
Esther helped him submit a formal review of the identification process and a request for the original clinical transfers. She advised him not to post the story online. The instruction was almost a relief. Several friends had said social media might produce an answer in a day, and Damian had felt both tempted and ill at the thought of strangers examining photographs of Iris alongside photographs of living women.
His oldest friend, Martin, came over on Friday with food from a bakery and asked whether Damian had slept. Damian said enough. Martin put the food on the counter and looked at the stacked papers.
Martin returned the next Wednesday with a square tin of biscuits and the expression of a man who had been rehearsing a difficult question on the bus. He was one of the few people Damian had not lost after Iris died. That was not because Martin had always chosen the right words. At the funeral he had told Damian he would soon have to learn to live again, and Damian had refused to speak to him for six weeks. Martin had apologised without arguing. Since then he had learned that practical help was sometimes a better measure of friendship than any interpretation of grief.
They cleared the kitchen table and laid out the flood records. Martin had kept his own notebook from the days he accompanied Damian to the emergency reception centre, a thick book with phone numbers on the back pages and coffee stains on the cover. He turned it over almost reluctantly. ‘I didn't know whether to bring this,’ he said. ‘Some of the things I wrote might be wrong.’
‘Then we'll mark them as wrong.’
The notes were uncomfortably familiar. Damian recognised the hurried handwriting from a time when Martin had been making calls because he could not trust himself to hold a pencil. Each page was dated. The first held addresses for three hospitals, a school gymnasium serving as a shelter and the telephone number of a regional missing-persons desk. The next contained a list of vehicles. On the third, a line had been drawn through the same hospital whose name appeared on Ruth's photograph. Beside it Martin had written ‘telephone diverted, ask tomorrow.’
When a local newspaper learned that an old identification was under review, the reporter who telephoned Damian sounded apologetic before he asked a question. His name was Callum Ford. He explained that the paper was preparing a feature about changes to emergency procedures since the flood. Someone had mentioned that one family's records were being reconsidered. He wanted to know whether Damian would speak about the experience. He said he could use no name if that was preferable, though he also acknowledged that anonymity could not be guaranteed in a small town where many people knew the original story.
Damian asked how the reporter had learned of the case. Callum said he could not identify his source. Damian felt anger rise at the possibility that someone handling private records had spoken carelessly. He asked for a day to consider the request. The reporter agreed and did not ask another question. After the call, Damian paced the kitchen until his hands stopped shaking. He had spent weeks trying to keep his hopes from becoming an announcement. The prospect of strangers discussing a possible daughter as a public mystery was unbearable.