Bank Manager Bet an Elderly Customer He Had No Money — Then the “Poor Man” Revealed He Was the Bank’s CEO

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Brian's team compared the two cards Quentin had kept with the customers' signatures on file, and both showed mismatches of the kind Esther Gallagher's card had shown: similar names, different hands. Then the team pulled the core-system audit trail for the East Liberty branch, and the trail told a story that was, in its way, even clearer than the signatures. Accounts were being opened from Dean Kavanagh's terminal, often after closing time, minutes after the customer's real transaction had been completed and the customer had left the building. A check cashed at four o'clock would be followed, at six-fifteen, by a new companion savings account in the same name, opened from Dean's terminal, with a signature card that would be filed the next morning. A money order purchased at eleven would be followed, at seven in the evening, by another. The pattern repeated, week after week, month after month, and it was not random. It followed the branch's busiest days, and it followed the customers who were least likely to notice a five-dollar fee or to have the time to dispute one: people cashing paychecks, people buying money orders, people making small deposits, people who came in on foot or by bus, people whose balances were small enough that a fee would hurt and whose lives were busy enough that a dispute would cost more than the fee itself.

By the end of the fifth week, the audit had a number, and the number was large enough to make Brian sit back in his chair and stare at it for a while before he called Elijah. One hundred and eighty-seven unauthorized companion savings accounts, opened over twenty-two months, with about thirty-eight thousand dollars in fees collected from them. The number was not, in the scale of a bank holding company with forty branches, a large amount of money. It was, in the scale of a waitress with two children and eighty dollars, an enormous amount. Elijah, when Brian told him the number on the phone, did not react the way Brian expected. He did not swear, and he did not ask how such a thing could have happened. He was quiet for a moment, and then he said, "Thirty-eight thousand dollars, taken five dollars at a time, from people who did not agree to give it. That is not a rounding error, Brian. That is a business model." And then he said, "Find every one of them. Every account, every fee, every customer. I want a list with names, and I want the money returned with interest, and I want a letter to each person, signed by me, that says what happened and that we are sorry, in plain language, without a lawyer's fingerprints all over it." Brian said he would do it, and Elijah believed him, because by then Elijah had seen enough of Brian's work to know that when Brian Doherty said he would find every account, he meant every account, down to the last five dollars.

Dean Kavanagh, when he was interviewed by Brian's team in the fourth week, denied that he had done anything wrong. He did not deny that the accounts existed. He did not deny that they had been opened from his terminal. He denied that they had been opened without consent. His claim, stated calmly and repeated in two separate interviews, was that the customers had agreed verbally, in conversation at the window, to open a companion savings account, and that the signatures on the cards were theirs, or close enough to theirs to count, and that the after-hours timing was simply a matter of paperwork being completed at the end of the day, when the branch was quiet and the staff could catch up on filing. He said that the companion savings product was a good product, that it helped customers save, and that the branch's new-account numbers reflected genuine customer interest, not manipulation. He said that the fees were disclosed, that the customers had been told, and that if some of them did not remember agreeing, that was a failure of memory, not a failure of consent. He said all of this in the measured tone of a man who has rehearsed his position and who believes, or has convinced himself, that it is true.

News in the same category

Bank Manager Bet an Elderly Customer He Had No Money — Then the “Poor Man” Revealed He Was the Bank’s CEO

45 Part