The board meeting at which Elijah presented the investigation's findings was held in the Keystone boardroom on a Tuesday morning, with the long table and the portraits of past chief executives on the wall, and with an atmosphere that Elijah, who had attended hundreds of such meetings, recognized as the particular quiet that falls over a room when the people in it know they are about to discuss something that cannot be undone. Brian presented the findings, in his plain language, with the numbers, the evidence, and the recommendations, and then he sat down, and the board asked questions, and Brian answered them, and then Elijah spoke, briefly, about the reforms and about the disclosure he wanted to make in the annual report. The discussion that followed was serious and, to Elijah's relief, not defensive. One board member asked whether the dismissal of Dean and the resignation of Sandra were sufficient, or whether the bank should pursue further action against them. Elijah said that the bank had dismissed Dean for cause, that Sandra had resigned during the investigation, that the evidence of falsified signature cards had been referred to the state regulator, and that the regulator would decide what further action, if any, was appropriate, and that Keystone would cooperate fully and would not prejudge the regulator's findings. Another board member asked whether the refunds and the reforms would be enough to restore customer trust at East Liberty, and Elijah said that trust was not restored by a single act but by a pattern of acts over time, and that the branch's job, now, was to produce that pattern, month after month, and that the board's job was to make sure the branch was given the time and the support to do it, rather than being pressured to return to the numbers it had produced before, which had been, in part, false. The board approved the reforms, and the disclosure, and the referral, and the meeting adjourned, and Elijah walked out of the boardroom feeling, not triumphant, but relieved, in the way a person feels relieved when a difficult truth has been told in a room full of people who needed to hear it and who did not flinch.
Dean Kavanagh, after his dismissal, did not disappear from the story, because people do not disappear from stories, even when they leave the building. Elijah learned, through Brian, that Dean had found work at a smaller financial firm in another city, in a role that did not involve managing a branch, and that he had told people there, when asked why he had left Keystone, that he had disagreed with the direction of the company, which was true in a narrow sense and incomplete in a broader one, and that he continued to maintain, to anyone who asked, that the customers had agreed verbally. Elijah did not pursue him, and did not ask Brian to monitor him, because he believed that a person's future employment was not Keystone's to police, and that the regulator, if it chose to act, would act on the evidence, and that Dean's own account of events would have to live alongside the record, which said what it said. He thought about Dean, sometimes, not with anger but with a kind of professional sadness, because Dean had been, by all accounts, a capable manager in many respects, organized, punctual, good with numbers, and because the same qualities that had made him capable had, when combined with a bonus that rewarded volume and a regional director who protected him, produced a result that harmed people who trusted him. Elijah had seen that combination before, in his career, and he knew that it was not rare, and that the only reliable defense against it was a system that checked, and that checked the checkers, and that made it safe for a deputy branch manager with a notebook to write things down.