Bank Manager Bet an Elderly Customer He Had No Money — Then the “Poor Man” Revealed He Was the Bank’s CEO

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Jorge Soto was forty-one, a warehouse supervisor who worked the night shift and slept during the day and who did his banking, when he could, in the late morning, in the narrow window between waking and going to work. He had come into the East Liberty branch about nine months before Elijah's Saturday to buy a money order, because his mother, who lived in another state, needed money for a medical bill and a money order was the way Jorge had always sent it. He had paid for the money order, taken his receipt, and left, and had thought nothing more about the visit until a statement arrived for an account he had never heard of, a companion savings account, with a balance of zero and a fee already charged against it. Jorge went back to the branch and asked, in the direct way of a man who works nights and does not have time for long conversations, how an account had been opened in his name without his knowledge. He was told, by a manager he identified in his statement as Dean Kavanagh, that he must have agreed to the account when he bought the money order, and that the account was a standard companion product, and that the fee was disclosed in the paperwork he had signed. Jorge said he had signed nothing except the money-order receipt, and Dean said, according to Jorge's statement, that the receipt included the agreement, and that Jorge should read his paperwork more carefully in future. Jorge, who reads English well but who was tired and who was standing in a bank in the middle of a workday, left without arguing further, and paid the fee, and then paid it again the next month, and then closed the account, paying a closing charge he resented, and told himself that the bank had won a small amount of money from him and that the lesson was to never buy a money order at that branch again. He did not complain to the regional office. He did not know, until Brian's team called him, that his experience was part of a pattern, and when he was told that it was, he was quiet for a moment, and then he said, "I thought it was just me. I thought I had missed something." That sentence, Brian would later tell Elijah, was the sentence he heard most often in the interviews, in different words, from different people: I thought it was just me.

These three stories, taken together, pointed in a direction that Brian's team followed with the care of people who know that a pattern is not a proof until the paper supports it. The paper, when they went looking for it, supported it in ways that were difficult to argue with. Quentin Sheehan, the deputy branch manager, came to Brian in the second week of the review with a notebook and two photocopies of signature cards, and he laid them on Brian's desk with the manner of a man who has been carrying something heavy and is relieved to finally set it down. The notebook was a plain, spiral-bound book, the kind sold in any drugstore, and in it Quentin had written, in a small, neat hand, dates and times and brief notes about accounts he had seen opened at the branch under circumstances that troubled him. He had begun the notebook, he told Brian, about a year earlier, after he had noticed that certain new accounts seemed to appear in the system on days when the customers in question had only come in for simple transactions, and after he had raised the matter once with Dean and been told that he was overthinking a sales program and that new accounts were good for the branch and good for the customers, who needed savings products whether they knew it or not. Quentin had not raised it again with Dean. He had started writing things down instead, and he had kept two signature-card copies, made on the branch copier on days when Dean was out of the office, because he had a feeling, he said, that the cards would not match the customers' real signatures, and that someone, someday, would need to see that.

News in the same category

Bank Manager Bet an Elderly Customer He Had No Money — Then the “Poor Man” Revealed He Was the Bank’s CEO

45 Part