Bank Manager Bet an Elderly Customer He Had No Money — Then the “Poor Man” Revealed He Was the Bank’s CEO

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Brian Doherty, meanwhile, had begun the way he always began: with paper. On Monday morning he went to the East Liberty branch before it opened, with two compliance analysts and a letter from Elijah authorizing a full review of the branch's operations. He did not begin with Dean. He began with the complaint log, because in Elijah's experience and in Brian's, a branch that treats one customer badly in public has usually treated other customers badly in private, and the place to find the pattern is the record of who complained and what happened next. What he found stopped him at his desk for a full minute. The log for the East Liberty branch showed a long list of complaints marked "pending branch review." Some of them had been pending for months. Some had been pending for more than a year. None of them, so far as Brian could tell from the log itself, had ever been forwarded to compliance, and none of them had a resolution noted. They were, in the language of the system, open. In the language of the customers who had filed them, they were unanswered.

Brian pulled the files behind the log entries, and then he pulled the regional office's records, and then he did something he had not expected to need to do: he called customers. The first call was to a woman who had complained, eight months earlier, that a fee had appeared on her account that she did not recognize. She told Brian that a person at the branch had told her the matter was "under review" and that someone would call her back, and that no one ever had. The second call was to a man who had complained about a second account he had not opened. He told Brian the same thing: "under review," and then silence. The third call, and the fourth, and the fifth, all told the same story with different details. By the end of the week, Brian had a list of nineteen customers who had been told their complaints were under review and who had heard nothing further, and he had a name for the person who had kept them that way: Sandra Byrne, the regional director, Dean Kavanagh's direct superior, a woman of fifty-two who had run the region for six years and who had a reputation, among the staff who worked for her, for being efficient, demanding, and intensely loyal to her own managers.

Sandra's method, as the investigation would establish it, was not complicated, and that was what made it effective. When a complaint about the East Liberty branch reached her office, she did not forward it to compliance. She did not close it. She marked it "pending branch review" in the system, which kept it technically open and therefore technically not overdue in any report that counted only closed complaints, and she told the customer that the matter was under review. Then she did nothing further, except, in some cases, to call Dean and tell him that a complaint had come in and that he should "handle it at the branch level," which in practice meant that Dean spoke to the customer, or did not, and the complaint stayed where it was. The customers, most of whom were people with small balances and long work hours and no particular faith that a bank would listen to them twice, mostly gave up. They paid the fees, or they closed their accounts, or they simply stopped asking. Sandra did not, so far as the investigation found, take money for herself. She did not alter a complaint's wording. She simply kept complaints from traveling to the people whose job it was to act on them, and she did it, the investigation concluded, because she believed that her region's numbers looked better when its problems stayed inside the region, and because she had come to think of Dean as one of her people and of complaints about him as attacks on her judgment in having promoted him. The investigation stated her motives only that far, and no further, because Brian Doherty was careful about the difference between what a record shows and what a person intended, and the record showed the pocketing, clearly, and the intention could only be inferred from the pattern, which was consistent and long.

News in the same category

Bank Manager Bet an Elderly Customer He Had No Money — Then the “Poor Man” Revealed He Was the Bank’s CEO

45 Part