Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The first complaint was from 2011. A man stopped for a broken taillight on Beatties Ford Road alleged that Officer Krol had cursed at him, ordered him out of the car without cause, and held him on the roadside for forty minutes before releasing him without a citation. Finding: unfounded. Reviewing supervisor: Sergeant D. Hutchins. The second complaint was from 2012, a woman who alleged she had been handcuffed during a noise call and left cuffed on her own porch while Krol searched her car; she had photographs of her wrists. Finding: unfounded. Reviewing supervisor: Sergeant D. Hutchins. Faith read the third, and the fourth, and by the fifth she had stopped reading the allegations and had begun reading only the last two lines of each file, the finding and the signature, the way you read a column of figures you already suspect. Unfounded, Hutchins. Unfounded, Hutchins. Unfounded, Hutchins. Fourteen complaints across sixteen years. Four alleging excessive force, one of them supported by an emergency room record. Three alleging unlawful detention, one of them a detention of twenty-two minutes that ended, like Dana Whitfield's, with no charge and no apology and a citizen who had gone to the trouble of writing it all down. Five for discourtesy and profanity. Two for the camera, for the lens that was off when it should have been on, in 2019 and again in 2023, each closed with a note that the officer had been counseled, although there was no record of counseling in the file, only the note that said there had been. And every one of them, every single one, reviewed and closed and signed by Sergeant Dale Hutchins, who had been Brian Krol's field training officer, who had taught him the job in a cruiser at three in the morning, who played poker with him on Thursdays, and who had retired, Faith noted, checking the date twice, eleven months ago, to a lake house in Denver, North Carolina, a fact she set down in her notebook without yet knowing that another file in another building contained a lake house in the same small town, purchased with money that had been promised to veterans, the two houses sitting in the same zip code like an accidental rhyme that no one in either case would ever remark on.

She carried the laptop down the hall to her captain with the screen still lit. The captain read standing up. He read the column of signatures the way she had read it, and then he did the thing that told Faith Okafor she had not over-read the pattern: he picked up the phone and called the chief's office himself, on a Saturday, and said, "We have a second problem inside the first one, and you are going to want to see it before the lawyers describe it to you."

By Monday morning, the day Dana Whitfield rose in Judge Marsh's courtroom to begin picking a jury, the department's machinery had produced its first documents. Brian Krol was placed on administrative leave, with pay, pending the outcome of an internal affairs investigation, his badge and department weapon surrendered at a desk in a room with a camera that was, everyone in the room was careful to confirm, recording. Tom Reilly was placed on administrative leave as well, on the narrower ground that he had participated in a detention he had not questioned, although the file noted, in language his union representative would later read with gratitude, the audio from his own camera, which had been running, and his announcement before removing the cuffs, and the fact that he had answered the United States Attorney's question before his senior officer could. The third officer, whose name appeared in the file as having remained at the vehicles, was returned to duty with a letter. And the department's chief, in a statement that was read at a press conference Dana did not attend and did not watch, said that the detention of a federal prosecutor in a courthouse parking deck was under investigation at every level, that the department had referred the matter, on its own motion, to the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice and to the FBI for independent review, that body-worn camera compliance was being audited department-wide back five years, and that the review of prior complaints against the involved officers had been reopened under new supervision, every file, without exception. He did not say the number fourteen. The number fourteen appeared in the newspapers two days later anyway, because numbers in files have a way of walking out of buildings, and when it appeared, the column of signatures appeared with it, and Dale Hutchins, eleven months into his retirement, received a call at his lake house from a reporter for the Charlotte Observer, and said, in the only statement he would ever give on the matter, that he had reviewed every complaint on its merits and that a complaint was what a criminal filed when the handcuffs hurt his feelings, and hung up, and the sentence ran in the paper exactly as he had said it, and did his case, in the court of everyone who read it, considerably more harm than his silence would have.

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part