Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Dana's opening statement took forty-one minutes, and she delivered it the way she had rehearsed it in the car at dawn a week before, except that a week before there had been no jury, and now there were twelve faces, and she spoke to the faces and not to the room. She told them about a promise. She told them that the evidence would show a charity built on the photographs of other men's service, and a founder who discovered that gratitude, in America, is a river that does not ask for receipts. She told them about three hundred and forty-one invoices, and she watched the number land, the way she had watched it land in the grand jury, in a small collective movement of the jurors' shoulders, because three hundred and forty-one is not a number a person can hold as an abstraction; it has weight; it has to be set down somewhere. She told them about a mailbox store on Independence Boulevard where three of the four vendors received their mail in box 114, between the packing tape and the greeting cards, and the young grocery manager in the second row wrote something down. She told them the evidence would show where the money went: not to ramps, not to roofs, not to rides to the hospital, but in a long quiet fan of transfers that came back, again and again, to the defendant, to his accounts, to his mortgage, to a lake house in Denver, North Carolina, that appeared in no brochure. And she told them, near the end, about the green clothbound ledger, the charity's own book, and she said the sentence she had been carrying since October like a stone in her pocket: "The defense will tell you this was sloppy bookkeeping. Ladies and gentlemen, sloppy bookkeeping does not forge a signature. Hold that thought, because near the end of this trial I am going to show you the defendant's mother's signature, in the charity's own book, and I am going to show you eleven places where it is not her signature at all, and I am going to ask you to decide what kind of man practices his mother's handwriting until he can sign her name to forty-eight thousand dollars." Gregory Lawson, at the defense table, did not move. Richard Voss wrote nothing on his legal pad. The foreperson-that-would-be wrote for a long time.

Voss's opening was shorter and, in its way, as good. He did not deny the money had moved. He denied that movement was theft. He described a charity that had grown too fast, a founder overwhelmed, vendors who had taken deposits and vanished in the wreckage of a bad economy, a bookkeeping system held together by a seventy-one-year-old volunteer and by hope. He used the word chaos the way other lawyers use a drum. He told the jury that the government, faced with a mess, had done what governments do: it had found the man whose name was on the door and called the mess a crime, because a crime has a defendant and a mess does not. He did not mention the signatures. He did not mention the mailbox store. He ended on the theme he would return to for two weeks, that suspicion is not proof and that the government's elegant story was a story, arranged by a storyteller, and that they should be careful of storytellers. It was well done. Dana, listening, marked the places where he had stepped around the evidence the way a man steps around furniture in a dark room he claims not to have entered, and she was content.

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part