Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 42

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

In March, at the invitation of the police academy and with the written blessing of two public affairs offices that had negotiated the invitation like a treaty, Dana spoke for one hour to a combined class of police recruits and first-year prosecutors in a lecture hall in Charlotte, on the subject, as the syllabus put it, of documentation and discretion. She had agreed to do it for one reason, which she did not put on the syllabus: Tom Reilly was in the instructor course by then, and he had asked, through channels, whether she would come, and she had decided that a request that traveled through that many channels deserved a yes. She stood at the lectern in her arguing suit with no notes, because the material did not require notes, and she told them, first, about paper. She told them that every case they would ever work would come down to a contest between what people said had happened and what had been written down at the time, and that the written thing won, almost always, and that this was not cynicism but the closest thing the law had to a law of physics. She told them about a green ledger and a signature with a loop that did not close. She told them about a dispatch log and a ninety-second recording and an audit trail for a camera, and about how a morning that three men might have described in three ways had been described, instead, by machines, identically, forever. Then she told them about the other side of the lectern's subject, which was discretion, and the room, which had been taking notes in the manner of people who expect an examination, put its pens down in the manner of people who have recognized a story.

"Sixteen years before I met him," she said, "an officer in this city began accumulating complaints. Fourteen of them. Excessive force. Unlawful detention. Profanity. A camera that was off when it should have been on, twice. Every one of those complaints was written down by a citizen, signed, and sent in, which is the bravest and most ordinary thing a citizen can do. And every one of them was closed, as unfounded, by the same reviewing sergeant, who had trained the officer, and who played poker with him on Thursdays. I want you to understand that the system did not fail to receive the information. The information arrived, fourteen times, in order, with signatures. The system had arranged, in advance, not to hear it, by putting one interested man in the doorway and calling him a review." She let that stand for a moment. "In October, that officer detained me in a parking garage. I am not going to describe it, because it is in a file and some of it is in a courtroom this spring, and because you can read. I am going to tell you what I have told the investigators, which is that I am the fifteenth complaint. The only difference between me and the other fourteen is that my supervisor arrived with a camera and that my name is on the building where I work. Fourteen people told the truth to a system that had decided not to hear them, and the fifteenth was heard because she could not be ignored. If you take one sentence out of this room, take this one: the person in front of you is a document that has not been written yet. Treat them the way you would want the record to read, because one way or another, in this century, there is going to be a record, and the only question your career will ever really ask you is whether you behaved as if you knew that before the machines reminded you."

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part