Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

By the end of the first week the government's case had a shape that the jurors could carry home in their heads, and Dana, reviewing her list at her kitchen counter at night, allowed herself to cross off whole lines of it in red pencil. Promise: done. Mechanism: done. Money: done, except the lake house, which would take one more witness and one more poster. Cost: begun, with Earl, and held in reserve, with Bessie Ann Whitaker waiting for the second week like a held note. What remained was the heart of it, the thing the whole case had been bending toward since Laura Bennett had stood in her doorway with a plastic sleeve: the book. The green clothbound ledger was exhibit forty-one, and the signature chart was exhibit fifty-two, and Dana had scheduled them for the following Tuesday, with Laura on the stand to walk the jury through six years of a mother's handwriting and eleven pages where the handwriting was a lie. She had not decided, until that weekend, whether to be afraid of Tuesday. The ledger was her best document and her most dangerous one, because it was the point where the case stopped being about Gregory Lawson's money and became about Gregory Lawson's mother, and juries, in Dana's experience, did not forgive prosecutors who appeared to enjoy that transition. She would have to walk into the most damning evidence in the trial carrying it as if it were heavy. As if it grieved her. The secret, which was not a secret to anyone who had watched her work that week, was that it did. It grieved her genuinely, and in the second week of the trial of Gregory Lawson, the woman he had tried to remove from the room was going to stand up and grieve, on the record, for the woman who had tried to remove her, and then she was going to prove, loop by loop and cross by cross, what the son had done to the mother's name.

The ledger came into the courtroom on Tuesday morning in an evidence box, carried by a marshal, and it is worth pausing on the object itself, because the jury saw it before they understood it and objects, in a courtroom, testify first. It was a green clothbound book, the kind that accountants used before the world moved onto screens, its corners rubbed pale, its spine lettered in a hand that had faded to brown: CAROLINA VETERANS RELIEF FUND, DISBURSEMENTS. It had the heft and the smell of a church record, which is what, in a sense, it was. Dana had it marked and admitted without objection, because Voss could hardly object to the charity's own book, and then she did the thing she had planned for a month. She did not open it. She called Laura Bennett.

Laura took the stand in a gray suit with her silver hair drawn back, carrying nothing, because everything she needed was already in the room, and she was sworn, and she gave her qualifications in the flat tone of a woman who has given them forty times: forensic accountant, twenty-three years, certified fraud examiner, employed by the United States Attorney's office for the Western District of North Carolina, previously with a bank, previously with a firm. Dana walked her first through the reconciliation, the boring and essential part, the matching of the book to the bank's records, check by check, until the jury understood that the green book was not an allegation but a mirror: what the book said went out, the bank confirmed went out, three hundred and forty-one times. Then Dana had the book itself brought to the witness, and had her open it, and the courtroom heard the small sound the binding made, and Dana said, "Ms. Bennett, whose handwriting records the disbursements in this book?"

"The entries are recorded in one hand throughout," Laura said. "The treasurer's. Margaret Lawson, the defendant's mother, served as volunteer treasurer for the entire period covered by the book. The entries are in her hand. The release signatures are also, with exceptions I will describe, in her hand."

"Exceptions," Dana said. "Tell the jury about the exceptions."

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part