Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

There is a temptation, in telling a story like this one, to make the mother into the villain of the son's story or the victim of it, and the file refuses both, because the file contains her signature in two hands, hers and the forged one, and it contains her photographs of an innocent woman's car, and it contains the 911 recording in which her voice shakes with a fear that was partly real, because she was afraid, truly afraid, of the thing that was coming for her family, and had simply chosen to meet it with a crime instead of with the truth. The truth would have been bearable to say. It would have sounded like this: my son put the book in my hands and I signed what he gave me and I never looked, and some of what is in the book I did not even sign, and I do not know when my son became a man who would practice his mother's handwriting. She never said it. Not to the agent, not to the public defender, not to her sister in Ohio who had wired the money and asked, in the single phone call the bond permitted to be ordinary, what on earth she had been thinking. "I was thinking of Gregory," Peggy said, and her sister, who had known her for sixty-eight years, said, "Yes. That is the whole trouble, Peg. It always was," and the call ended, and Peggy put the phone down gently, the way you set down something that belongs to someone else.

Dana spent the weekend the way the list on her kitchen counter instructed, minus the item that said sleep. On Saturday she drove to her father's house in Huntersville with a bag of groceries he had not asked for, and she made soup in his kitchen while he sat at the table doing the crossword in the newspaper that had his daughter's case in it, on page three, below the fold, in a story he had read twice and would not discuss unless she began. Her father, Robert Whitfield, was seventy-six, a retired school principal, a man who had integrated a faculty in 1974 and had been describing it ever since as merely the schedule working out, and he had raised two daughters on the theory that the world would not grade them on a curve and that they should therefore never ask it to. His wife, Dana's mother, had been dead for six years, and the house kept her arrangements the way a church keeps a departed organist's music, in order, in place, untouched by any hand but his.

"You are in the paper," he said, at last, not looking up from the crossword.

"I know, Daddy."

"They spelled Whitfield right. That is new." He turned a page. "Your mother used to say the news would spell it wrong at your funeral and she would have to come back and correct it personally." He was quiet a moment. "A word of nine letters. Annoys, but legally. Third word is an R."

"Harasses," Dana said.

"No. Nine letters, third is R." He frowned at the grid. "Persecute. That is nine and the third is R. Persecute." He wrote it in, and then, in the same tone he had used for the clue, he said, "Did he hurt you, baby?"

"No. He scared me and he shamed me and he put his hands on me in front of a woman who had arranged for it, and I have been a prosecutor for eleven years and I stood there with my own car chirping behind me like a witness nobody called. But he did not hurt me. The marks were gone by dinner."

"And the woman."

"The woman is charged. I am not allowed to be involved in her case, and I am not. I try her son on Monday."

"I know you do." He set the paper down. "I want to tell you a thing I have never told you, because it did not concern you until Friday. In 1974, the year of the schedule working out, a deputy came to the school to serve a paper on a teacher of mine, a good man, over a debt that was not his, a confusion of names, the same surname as another man across the county. And the deputy would not hear it. He served it in the hallway, in front of the man's students, because the paper said a name and the name was on the door. It took four months to undo. The man never stood in a hallway the same way again. I have thought about that deputy for fifty years, Dana. Not with hatred. With interest. Because I believe he was not a cruel man. I believe he was a man who had been taught that the paper in his hand was the truth and that the person in front of him was an obstacle to it. And the whole of my working life, I tried to run a school where the person in front of you outranked the paper. That is all I have to say. It is not advice. You are forty-one and you try cases for the United States. It is a story."

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part