Earl Dotson testified on Thursday morning. He came into the courtroom in a suit that his daughter had bought him for the occasion, with his veteran's cap in his hands because he had been told he could not wear it on the stand and had decided to carry it instead, and he was sworn, and he sat in the witness chair with the cap in his lap and answered Dana's questions in the plain order she had arranged for him. He was seventy-four. He lived in Gastonia. His wife, Marlene, had had a stroke in the spring of the year in question, and the house they had lived in for forty years had three steps at the front and four at the back, and a woman cannot be carried up steps forever by a man of seventy-four, although he had done it, he said, for five months, and the jury should understand that he was not complaining about that part. He had written to the charity. He described the letters he had received in return, and Dana had them marked and put up on the screen, warmly worded, on the charity's letterhead with the flag in the corner, explaining that funds were being allocated and that his patience was appreciated and that men like him were the reason the charity existed. He had received that letter twice. The second time it was the same letter, he said, except the date. Dana let that sit. Then she asked him what he had done, and he said he had built the ramp himself, out of lumber he bought on a credit card he was still paying on, with a neighbor's borrowed saw, over six weekends, and that Marlene had cried the first time she went down it under her own power, and that he had been ashamed of the crying because he had thought a man should be able to give his wife a ramp without it costing either of them that. "Mr. Dotson," Dana said, "did anyone from the Carolina Veterans Relief Fund ever build anything at your house?" "No ma'am." "Did anyone from the charity ever come to your house at all?" "No ma'am." "Did the charity ever return any money to you, or pay any part of the cost of the ramp you built?" "No ma'am. They sent the letter." She thanked him and sat down, and Voss, who was no fool, asked him three gentle questions and let him go, and Earl Dotson walked out of the courtroom carrying his cap, past the defense table, past the empty second row, past the government's table where Dana did not look up from her notes because she had learned that a prosecutor who watches her witnesses leave looks like she is admiring her own work, and the trial moved on to the bank records, which is to say it moved on to the long gray accumulation, arranged, brick by brick, into a wall.
The bank records took three days. Dana had known they would and had budgeted the jury's patience for them the way a general budgets water. She put the records custodian on for an hour and the bank's analyst on for a day, and she walked the money through the courtroom in exhibits the size of posters, because she believed that a juror who has seen money move on a wall understands it in the body in a way that no summary can teach. Check from the charity to Tarheel Accessibility Solutions, eleven thousand four hundred dollars, for the ramp at the vacant lot in Gastonia. Deposit. Transfer out, nine thousand, to an account at another bank in the name of a company that existed for eleven months and filed nothing. Transfer out again, and again, each hop smaller, each hop taking its toll of fees and fog, until the money arrived, thinned and laundered of its letterhead, in an account whose signature card bore one name, in a hand the jury would come to know. She did not hurry. On the second day of the records she watched the retired engineer in the front row begin, unconsciously, to nod at each hop, the way a man nods at a engine he is diagnosing, and she knew the wall was holding. On the third day Voss cross-examined the analyst for two hours on the theme of chaos, of commingled funds and innocent explanations, and the analyst, who had the personality of a glacier and the preparation of Laura Bennett behind her, conceded everything that was true and nothing that mattered: yes, legitimate businesses also move money between accounts; no, legitimate businesses do not ordinarily move it in circles back to the founder's mortgage; no, in twenty years she had not seen a legitimate vendor whose entire corporate existence fit inside box 114 of a mailbox store. The jury laughed, once, at that, a short involuntary sound that Voss pretended not to hear and that Dana pretended not to have caused, and Judge Marsh called the lunch recess with the air of a woman closing a door before anything else could get out.