Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That night, the Charlotte Observer ran the trial story above the fold, and for the first time the two cases, the fraud case and the deck case, appeared in the same article, side by side in adjacent columns like the two houses in Denver, North Carolina, an accidental rhyme that no editor remarked on: the prosecutor proving that the defendant had framed his mother in ink, while the mother sat at home under bond conditions, forbidden the courtroom, charged with trying to frame the prosecutor in a parking deck. Dana read it at her kitchen counter with the red pencil in her hand and the trial list in front of her, and she did not cross anything off. She sat for a while with the paper open. Then she called Earl Dotson's daughter, who had been waiting to hear how her father had done, and told her that he had done beautifully and that the jury had listened to every word, and the daughter cried a little, with relief, and Dana, who did not ordinarily allow herself to be the person prosecutors are in movies, stayed on the phone until the crying was done and the ordinary conversation about the drive home and the ramp and Marlene's good days had reasserted itself, because she had learned in eleven years that the cases are made of paper but the verdicts are made of people, and people require, among other things, that someone stay on the phone.

Bessie Ann Whitaker testified on Thursday of the second week, and she was the witness Dana had been holding like a note. She was fifty-nine, from Monroe, with her hair in a gray braid and her husband's wedding ring worn on a chain because his hands had changed and hers had not, and she brought into the courtroom the thing that bank records and signature charts, for all their power, cannot bring, which was duration. Nineteen months. Dana established it the way she established everything, in order, with documents, but the documents this time were a family's calendar. The bathroom conversion had been approved by the charity in a letter that Bessie Ann had kept on her refrigerator under a magnet shaped like a strawberry, and Dana put the letter on the screen, and there it was, the flag in the corner, the warm wording, the promise of six weeks. Six weeks became nineteen months of a husband washed in a kitchen, of a grown man, a soldier who had carried a radio through two deployments, being lifted by his wife and a home-health aide whose hours the insurance counted like coins. Bessie Ann did not perform her testimony. She answered. She answered the way people answer who have repeated the facts to agencies and churches and cousins until the facts have worn smooth: without heat, without tears, with the terrible evenness of a person reading a meter. It was Voss who made the mistake, if it can be called a mistake, of asking her on cross whether she blamed the charity or blamed circumstances, whether she understood that organizations fail people without anyone stealing, whether it was possible that her family's suffering had been, in his word, administrative. Bessie Ann Whitaker looked at him for a moment with an expression that Dana, from the government's table, recognized as the expression of a woman deciding whether a question deserves the dignity of anger. "Sir," she said, "I don't know about administrative. I know I got a letter that said six weeks, and I know my husband got a bath in the kitchen for nineteen months, and I know somebody built a lake house. You can call that what you want to. I call it the difference between the letter and the house." Judge Marsh did not intervene. The jury wrote. Voss thanked the witness and sat down, and the government, in the silence that followed, called its final witness, a title examiner from Gaston County, who established in twenty dry minutes the purchase of the lake house in Denver, North Carolina, its price, its financing, and the source of the down payment, traced through three accounts back to a disbursement signed, in the green book, with a loop that closed like a noose. And then Dana stood, in the well of the court, in her arguing suit, and said the four words that fourteen months had been walking toward: "The United States rests."

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part