Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 41

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Witness preparation, Dana discovered, was the strangest room in the whole architecture, because it was her own office with the chairs rearranged. Achebe sat where her witnesses had sat for eleven years, with a notebook and a list, and she sat where she had never sat, on the other side of her own desk, with her hands folded, learning what every witness she had ever prepared had learned: that your own morning, the one you lived, becomes in the telling a foreign country whose customs are cross-examination. He walked her through it with a care she recognized, because it was hers. Answer the question asked. Do not argue with the defense lawyer; he is not the jury. If you do not remember, say so; the record will remember for you. When he asks about the handcuffs, describe the handcuffs. When he asks whether you were frightened, you may say you were frightened; you are not on trial for your composure. And when he suggests, as he will suggest, that the whole affair was a misunderstanding that others escalated, you will not correct his theory of the case. You will say what the woman shouted, and what you said, and what the officer answered, and you will stop.

"He will ask me about the trial," Dana said. "About Gregory. He will try to make me the prosecutor of the mother, out for the family. He will ask whether I bore a grudge."

"And you will say that you recused yourself within the hour and have made no decision in this case, and that the file will bear that out, because it will, because you did." Achebe turned a page. "Ms. Whitfield, I have read your statement four times. It is eleven pages and there is not a wasted word in it, which is more than I can say for any witness I have ever prepared, including two judges. The defense's problem is not your testimony. The defense's problem is that everything you will say is also on a recording. You are the only witness in the case whose entire account can be checked against machines, and it checks. So my advice is the advice you have given a hundred witnesses, and I am aware of the symmetry, and I am going to give it anyway. Tell the truth, in order, and sit down."

She laughed, in her own office, in the witness's chair, and Achebe, startled, laughed too, and for a moment the spring case was just two lawyers in a room with a file, which is what, underneath the captions and the conditions and the columns of signatures, it had always also been. When he had gone, Dana sat for a while in the witness's chair, which she had never done, and looked at her office from the other side: the calendars on the wall, the new one now, with a new set of dates being crossed off in red pencil toward a spring trial in which she would be, for the first time in her career, exhibit and audience at once; the credenza, where the Lawson binders had been replaced by the ordinary accumulation of a working prosecutor, three new matters in their early, cardboard stages; and on the top of the nearest stack, where the mail clerk had left it that morning, a cardboard box. She had not ordered it and she knew, before she opened it, what it would be, because the boxes always came the same way, from another agency, with another spreadsheet built at two in the morning by another person who had noticed that something smelled. She opened it. Bank records. A spreadsheet. And a sticky note, in a hand she did not know, that said only: you will want to see page 40 first. She looked at page 40. She read it twice. She reached, without looking, for the red pencil, and then for a fresh legal pad, and she wrote at the top of the first page, in the hand her office would come to know as well as a certain jury had come to know another woman's: a name, a date, and the first question, which was the question she asked at the beginning of every case and the question that the whole of the last year had been, in the end, an extended education in asking. The question was: who signed for this. She turned the page, and began.

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part