Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

And Laura, who had reconciled everything four times, described them the way she had described them in Dana's doorway, except that now she had the screen, and the screen had the signatures ten feet tall. The genuine hand first: the jury saw Margaret Lawson's signature enlarged until it filled the wall, the great loop of the L that did not close but trailed off like a ribbon coming loose, the low cross on the t, the small tight hook at the end of the final n where the pen had been lifted by a woman in a hurry for six years in exactly the same place. "This is her signature," Laura said. "It appears, in my count, three hundred and thirty times in this book, across six years. It does not vary in its essential characteristics. A person's signature is a motor habit. It is as stable as a fingerprint and considerably harder to change, because it lives in the hand and not in the mind." Then the screen changed. "This is the release signature on a disbursement of forty-eight thousand dollars to Honor Roll Services, dated March of last year. I want you to look at the L." The loop on the wall closed like a noose. "Look at the cross on the t." It stood high, like a flag on a pole. "Look at the end of the name." The hook was gone; in its place, a careful flourish, the kind a person adds when they are drawing a signature rather than writing one. "This signature was not written by Margaret Lawson," Laura said. "It was drawn, slowly, by someone copying her hand. I found eleven of them. They appear only on the largest disbursements in the book, all within a single season, and they total three hundred and ninety-one thousand dollars, which is to say, they total more than the rest of the charged conduct combined. Whoever drew them had extended access to the book or to pages from it, and had practiced. The earliest attempts are the worst. By the eleventh, the copy is good enough to pass a bank. It would not pass a forensic comparison, and it did not."

The courtroom was quiet in the specific way that courtrooms are quiet when twelve people are doing arithmetic about a person's soul. Dana let the quiet work for exactly as long as she had planned, and then she asked the question that the whole trial had been built to hold, in the voice she had used in the deck when she announced her own name to the men holding her arms, level and clear and meant to be recorded.

"Ms. Bennett. In your twenty-three years of examining fraud, have you encountered this pattern before: a principal in a scheme who forges the signature of a family member, in advance, on the largest transactions?"

"I have encountered it four times," Laura said. "In each case, the purpose was the same. The forger was creating a documentary record in which the largest losses would be attributed, if the scheme were discovered, to the family member. It is a form of insurance. The family member's signature becomes the place where the blame is designed to land. In my professional opinion, that is what this book shows. The eleven forged releases were written so that, if this charity were ever examined, the largest disbursements in it would appear to have been authorized by Margaret Lawson. Not by her son."

At the defense table, Gregory Lawson looked down at his hands and did not look up for a long time. Dana saw it without appearing to see it. She also saw, in the jury box, the school nurse in the front row turn her face, briefly and involuntarily, toward the empty second row of the gallery, toward the place where the mother of the defendant was not sitting and would never sit, because of conditions read aloud in another courtroom by a magistrate while she nodded along in orange. Dana had not arranged that glance and could not have. It was the trial arranging itself, the way she had always believed a true case would, given paper enough and time.

Voss's cross-examination was the best forty minutes of lawyering Dana had ever seen him do, and she respected it even as she dismantled it in her notebook. He could not attack the comparison; Laura was unattackable, a glacier with a certificate. So he attacked the inference. A forged signature, he suggested, proved a forger, not a defendant's state of mind. Others had access to the book: the office manager, the bookkeeper who came after, volunteers. The mother herself, he suggested, with a delicacy that fooled no one, might have varied her own hand in a season of illness, arthritis, grief, her husband long dead and her health not what it was. Laura listened to all of it with her hands folded. "Mr. Voss," she said, "a person's signature does not develop a closed loop in March and lose it in April and regain it for six more years. Arthritis degrades a signature. It does not improve its resemblance to a tracing. As to access: I examined the book's custody at the government's request. The book was kept, throughout the period, in one of two places. The charity's office, in a locked cabinet, or the home of the treasurer. The defendant had keys to both. I am not aware of another person who did." And when Voss, in his final question, attempted to suggest that all of this was misdirection, that the mother was a distraction the government had dressed up as a victim to perfume a bookkeeping case, Laura Bennett said the sentence that Dana would hear repeated, months later, by people who had not been in the room: "Counselor, I did not choose whose signature was forged. I only measured the loops. The loops chose."

News in the same category

Handcuffed Beside Her Own Car

45 Part