The defense case lasted a day and a half, and it was, as Dana had predicted in October, an argument in search of witnesses. Voss called the charity's former office manager, a harried woman who testified truthfully that the office had been chaotic, that vendors had been paid late and sometimes twice, that Gregory Lawson had been, in her phrase, a big-picture person, and who then, under Dana's three questions on cross, agreed that she had never seen a vendor perform any work, had never visited a job site, and had prepared invoices, on Gregory's instruction, from figures he gave her over the phone, for companies whose names she had first heard when he said them. He called an accountant of his own, a hired expert with a bow tie and a theory, who testified that the records were consistent with disorganization, and who, under Dana's cross, conceded that disorganization does not ordinarily register three of its vendors to the same mailbox, does not ordinarily route its mistakes in circles back to the founder's mortgage, and does not, in his experience, forge the treasurer's signature eleven times on the largest checks, although he allowed, bravely, that he was an accountant and not a handwriting expert, to which Dana replied, "No further questions," in a tone that the transcript would render as neutral and that everyone in the room understood completely. He did not call Gregory. It had been the open question of the trial for two weeks, in the press, in the hallway, in Dana's own head at her kitchen counter, and by the second week she had known the answer the way you know weather: he could not take the stand, because the stand would require him to answer, under oath and under her questioning, for the eleven signatures, and there was no version of that answer that did not either confess the forgery or accuse his mother of it, and Richard Voss, whatever else he was, was not a man who would let his client accuse his mother of a forgery from the witness chair in a federal courtroom while she sat at home with an ankle's worth of conditions and a spring court date. So Gregory Lawson sat, and listened, and exercised his constitutional right to silence, which Judge Marsh explained to the jury with scrupulous fairness, and the defense rested on Friday morning, and the courtroom exhaled, and the case became what all cases become at the end: two stories, told one last time, to twelve people who would carry them into a room and not come out until they had chosen.
Dana's closing took an hour and ten minutes. She did not raise her voice in it. She had decided, long before, that this case would be closed at the volume of a person reading a ledger aloud, because the ledger was the loudest thing in it. She walked the jury through the promise, the mechanism, the money, the cost, in the order she had promised them in her opening, because a prosecutor's opening is a contract and she had never once, in eleven years, failed to deliver the goods in the order she had listed them. She put the vacant lot on the screen. She put box 114 on the screen. She put the lake house on the screen, and Earl Dotson's ramp, the one he built himself, in a photograph his daughter had taken, the lumber still unpainted, beside it. And at the end she put up the two signatures, the true one and the drawn one, side by side, ten feet tall, the open loop and the closed one, and she stood under them and said the last thing she said to the jury in the trial of Gregory Lawson. "The defendant built his charity out of other people's trust. He built it out of yours, when you gave. He built it out of theirs," and she gestured, once, toward the gallery, where Earl Dotson's daughter sat and where Bessie Ann Whitaker sat with her husband's ring on its chain, "when they waited. And when he needed one more thing to build with, he used his mother's name, and he practiced it until it would pass a bank. Everything in this case was taken from people who could not afford to lose it, by a man who counted on the fact that no one would ever sit down and do the arithmetic. You have now done the arithmetic. It is on the wall. I am asking you to write it in the only place it has not yet been written, which is your verdict." She sat down. Voss closed for an hour on the theme of chaos and the burden of proof, and he was good, and it did not matter to the shape of the room, and everyone in the room knew both of those things at once, which is the particular tragedy of good lawyering in a lost cause. Judge Marsh charged the jury. The jury retired, at 3:40 on a Friday afternoon, with the green ledger in a box and three hundred exhibits and twelve notebooks, and the trial of Gregory Lawson passed out of the hands of everyone who had built it and into the hands of the twelve people it had been built for.