The question was so quietly practical that it took Vanessa a moment to feel the weight of it. She looked at the child, so small in the passenger seat of the sedan, and said, "You tell the truth, honey. Whatever it is you want to tell. You don't have to protect me."
"I wasn't going to," said Lily, and she climbed out of the car and walked up the front steps of the school with her hat pulled down and her back very straight.
Vanessa watched her until she disappeared through the doors. Then she put her forehead against the steering wheel and stayed there for a very long time.
The school day, as it turned out, was not quite as bad as she had feared and a good deal worse than she could have imagined.
In the first hour, no one said anything. Lily sat at her desk in the second row of Ms. Brandt's classroom with her blue hat low and her hands folded, and the other children, absorbed in their own picture day dramas, barely glanced at her. A boy named Tobias was loudly insisting that his tie was a snake. Two girls were comparing hair ribbons. A tiny, fierce child named Noor, with thick black braids and a missing front tooth, slid into the seat beside Lily and whispered, "Your hat is cool. Can I touch the pom-pom?"
"Okay," said Lily.
Noor touched it reverently. "It's like a cloud."
It was almost nice. It was almost normal. And then came the photographer.
He was a cheerful man with a ponytail and a camera on a tripod, and he had the children come up in rows to sit on a stool in front of a mottled blue backdrop. When Lily's turn came, she walked to the stool and sat down and folded her hands in her lap, and the photographer smiled and said, "Okay, sweetheart, let's take off the hat for the picture, shall we? Big smile!"
"I'd like to keep it on," said Lily.
"Oh, I know, it's a great hat. But the school likes to have a clear view of everybody's face. Just for a second."
"I'd like to keep it on," Lily said again, a little more firmly.
"It's only a picture! Come on, now, don't be shy." And before Ms. Brandt, who had been helping with the line, could cross the room, he reached out with one friendly hand and lifted the hat from her head.
The room went silent.
It was a short silence, a heartbeat or two, but it was an enormous one. Twenty-three first graders looked at the shorn, pale, round little skull of the girl on the stool, at the faint pink of her scalp showing through the fuzz, at her large gray-green eyes, suddenly enormous in her small face.
"Whoa," said Tobias, quite loudly. "Lily got shaved."
"Tobias," said Ms. Brandt sharply, arriving at last. She took the hat from the photographer's hand with a look that made him step backward. "That's enough."
"Why did she get shaved?" Tobias demanded. "Does she have bugs?"
"Tobias."
"My cousin had bugs and they shaved her too."
"I don't have bugs," said Lily. Her voice was steady, but her chin had begun to tremble. "It had tree sap in it."
"Oh," said Tobias, momentarily satisfied.
But another child giggled, and a second one whispered something to a third, and the ripple spread outward across the room like a stone through water. Lily sat motionless on the stool with her hands clenched in her lap, and she did not look at anyone, and she did not cry, and Ms. Brandt, who had been teaching for four years and had never once wanted to throw a camera across a room, knelt beside her and said very softly, "Lily, would you like to come with me for a minute?"
"I want my hat back."
"Yes. Of course. Here." Ms. Brandt placed it carefully on her head, settling it with both hands, and Lily pulled it low again. "Noor, would you like to come and sit with us in the library? Bring your picture day tie."
"I don't have a tie," said Noor, but she slipped her small hand into Lily's anyway and said, with great ferocity, "Anyone who laughs is a dumbhead."
"Noor!" said Ms. Brandt, but she was smiling a little as she said it, and her eyes were bright with something that was not quite laughter.