She Shaved Her Stepdaughter’s Mother’s Curls Off in Four Minutes, But She Never Saw This Ending Coming

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"You never have, which is a pity." She smiled thinly. "You are being too hard on yourself and not hard enough on the right thing. You did not fail to see. You chose to hope. That is not a flaw. That is what people do when they love someone and are lonely. But you also did not protect your daughter, and that is true, and you have to carry it. Those are both facts. You can hold both without drowning."

"Dr. Reyes says something like that."

"Dr. Reyes sounds like a sensible woman." She leaned forward. "And now the question. What do you want to do about the girl? Vanessa?"

"I don't know."

"Do you love her?"

The question hung between them. Daniel looked out the window at the white garden, at the empty swing moving gently in the wind.

"I did," he said slowly. "I think I still might. That's what I can't figure out. I don't know if the person I loved was real. Or if the one who picked up the clippers was the real one. Or whether there's a version of her who could be trusted, in this house, with my daughter. And I'm not sure I'm allowed to find out. Lily is the only thing I'm sure of. Everything else is fog."

"Then don't decide," said his mother. "Don't decide anything. Not yet. Not until the fog clears. Be patient, Daniel. You've always rushed to fix things. You're like your father. Sometimes the thing you need to do is wait."

"And if the fog never clears?"

"Then you'll know that too." She patted his hand. "Whatever you do, do it slowly. And do it with Lily. Not for her. With her. She's a good deal wiser than either of us."

"She really is," said Daniel.

Upstairs, in the bathroom, a faucet ran and a small voice began to sing, tuneless and happy, a song about a harbor seal. The two of them sat in the winter kitchen and listened, and neither of them said anything more.

Dr. Teresa Alvarez did not have a couch. She had two armchairs, a low wooden table with a box of tissues she never pushed toward anyone, and a window that looked out on a parking lot and a single stubborn maple tree. On Vanessa's first visit, she had simply said, "Tell me why you're here," and then waited. She had waited through four minutes of silence, a stretch that had felt to Vanessa like four hours, and when Vanessa finally began to speak, the doctor had not interrupted once.

That was in November. By the second week of December, Vanessa had come to know the room well: the faint smell of cedar, the cracked leather of the armchair, the way the afternoon light slid across the carpet at a quarter to four. She had learned not to look at the clock. She had learned that the tissues were there for use and not for judgment. And she had learned, with some reluctance, that there was a limit to how long a person could outrun a story.

"You keep saying I became my mother," said Dr. Alvarez, on the Tuesday before Christmas. She sat with a legal pad on her knee and her reading glasses pushed up into her gray hair. "I want to be curious about that phrase."

"It's accurate."

"Is it?" She tilted her head. "Your mother took scissors to a nine-year-old child as punishment, and told her that she would be grateful someday. She did it calmly. She did it without remorse. And in the twenty-five years since, did she ever apologize?"

"No."

"Did she ever acknowledge it?"

"She told people I'd been a difficult child. She said I'd 'asked for it.'"

"And on the night you cut Lily's hair, what did you do afterward?"

Vanessa looked down at her hands. "I cried. I couldn't stop crying. I told Lily I was sorry. I told Daniel everything the next morning. I didn't try to make it smaller. I left the ring on the table. I came here."

"So in what way," said Dr. Alvarez gently, "did you become her?"

It was a quiet question, and it landed like a stone in still water. Vanessa sat with it. The maple tree outside the window moved in the wind, its bare branches scratching at the glass.

"The first part," she said slowly. "The part where I picked up the clippers. That part was her. I was doing what had been done to me. I was repeating it. It came out of me like a reflex."

"Yes. That's what we call a repetition. It's very common, and very painful. People who were harmed as children often find themselves, in moments of overwhelm, reenacting the harm. It doesn't make them monsters. It makes them human, and wounded, and in need of repair."

News in the same category

She Shaved Her Stepdaughter’s Mother’s Curls Off in Four Minutes, But She Never Saw This Ending Coming

45 Part