Winter loosened its grip on Harbor Point in the usual reluctant way, with a week of false thaws and a week of freezing rain and a morning in early April when Daniel woke to the sound of dripping from every gutter on the street. The ice went out of the harbor with a groan like a great animal turning over in its sleep. The first crocuses pushed up through the gray lawn. And Lily, who had said nothing about the letter for three months, came down to breakfast on the second Saturday of the month, sat at the table, and announced, "I'm ready to mail it."
Daniel put down his coffee. "The letter to Vanessa?"
"Yes."
"Are you sure?"
"I'm sure." She said it quite calmly, spooning honey into her oatmeal. "I thought about it for a long time. I thought about it when I was sad, and when I was happy, and when Noor lost her tooth, and when I got a hundred on my spelling test. And I still want to. I think that means it's real."
"That's a very good way to test it."
"Dr. Reyes taught me. It's called letting it sit." She stirred. "I want to mail it. And I want to see her."
He had been expecting some version of this, and still it caught him off guard. He sat very still. "See her?"
"Not for a long time. Not alone. Just a little. With you. In a place with lots of people." She looked up, and her eyes, steady and gray-green, held his. "I want to look at her. I want to see if she's still the same."
"Is that what you need to know? If she's the same?"
"I think I need to know if she's different." Lily frowned. "Because if she's the same, then I'll know I was right to be scared. And if she's different, then I can stop."
"Stop what?"
"Being scared." She said it so simply that he almost missed it. "I'm tired of being scared of a person who isn't here. It's like being scared of a closet. I want to open the door."
He looked at her for a long moment. Then he reached across the table and took her hand. "Bug, you are the bravest person I know."
"I'm not brave. I'm curious."
"Those are very similar things."
They set it up through Dr. Reyes, who sat down with Daniel and Lily in the sea captain's house on Spruce Street the following Tuesday and walked through it with the thoroughness of a woman planning an expedition. The meeting would take place in her office, with Biscuit on the rug and a box of crayons on the table. It would last twenty minutes, no longer. Lily could leave at any moment, by raising a green card, which Dr. Reyes would keep in her pocket. Vanessa would sit in the chair by the window. She would not approach unless Lily did. She would not touch. She would speak only when invited.
"And if I don't want to say anything?" Lily asked.
"Then you don't say anything. You can look at her, and she can look at you, and that's the whole meeting."
"What if I want to ask her a question?"
"Then you can ask. And she'll answer honestly. That's her job. I've already talked with her therapist, and Vanessa has agreed to every one of these conditions." Dr. Reyes smiled faintly. "She said, and I quote, Whatever Lily needs. I'll sit on the floor if she wants."
"I don't want her to sit on the floor."
"I'll make a note."
Daniel sat with his hands clasped and said nothing. The afternoon sun slanted through the tall windows and fell across the rug where the dog lay, and the whole room smelled of tea and pencil shavings. Part of him wanted to snatch his daughter up, run out of the house, and never come back. Another part of him, the part that had read Claire's letter on a snowy morning in November, knew with perfect certainty that this was necessary.
They scheduled it for the following Thursday.
Vanessa came early. She sat in the car outside the sea captain's house with her hands pressed between her knees and her breath coming too fast. Then she did what Dr. Alvarez had taught her. She named five things she could see: the white clapboard of the house, the green door, the bare branches of the old pear tree, the black iron railing, a robin hopping on the lawn. She named four things she could hear, three she could feel, two she could smell. By the time she reached one thing I can taste, the buzzing in her ears had faded, and she could stand.