Outside, up the slope, Grady's flags stood in the snow around the Alpine Rest in a neat red row, marking the house like a sentence underlined — and at the kitchen window, small and steady in the winter dusk, Cate's lamp came on, on time, as it always did, in a house whose mistress kept her accounts, and her appointments, and her reason, in perfect order.
The trap had been set for nine days, and on the ninth night it was Cate who nearly forgot it was a trap at all.
She had written the false entry on a Tuesday, in the blue-bound diary she had kept since the last bad year of her marriage, in her ordinary hand, neither hurried nor careful — a lie told to catch a thief must look exactly like the truth told to no one. *November the twenty-eighth,* she had written. *I dreamed of Anton again. If he ever asks, let him be told: I kept nothing of his. The papers he wanted are where I put them the winter before the explosion, folded inside Mother's green scarf, in the cedar box, under the floor of the pantry, where the cold keeps everything honest.*
There was no green scarf. There had never been a green scarf. Cate's mother had owned exactly one good scarf, grey wool, and Cate had buried her in it. There were no papers, no cedar box, no pantry hiding place. The whole entry was a small, cold invention, built the way she had built the false hymn in the old diary years before, when she had learned that her husband read everything she wrote — and that the only private country left to her was the country of things not quite true.
She left the diary on the sitting-room table, beneath the lamp, for nine days. She left it while Pearl kneaded bread, while the carpenters finished the stair rail, while Vera Kestrel's man came to "inspect the flue" and Vera's seamstress called to measure curtains Cate had never ordered, and while the speaking tube, capped by Pearl with cork and flannel, stood silent behind the wall like a held breath.
On the ninth night the wind came down off the pass with snow in it, and the house settled early.
Cate was in the kitchen, drying the last dishes, when Pearl touched her elbow and only tilted her head toward the sitting room. Rowan was already there, standing in the shadows beside the bookcase with one hand pressed flat against the wall, where he had waited twenty minutes beside the capped speaking tube.
The voice began the way it always began: not a knock, not a bell, but a breath, shaped by the brass mouth of the tube into something like a man clearing his throat in another room of his own house.
"Catherine."
Cate set the dish towel down on the edge of the sink. She did it slowly, fold over fold, because her hands had begun, traitorously, to shake, and she had promised herself, in the nine days of waiting, that whatever else she did when this moment came, she would not let the shaking make her decisions for her.
"Catherine, you are keeping strangers in my house."
Rowan did not move. Pearl, at the kitchen door, crossed herself once, out of a childhood habit she had mocked in herself for twenty years, and then stood very still with her arms folded, as if she were listening to a weather report.
"You have let them eat at my table," the voice said. It was Anton's voice. Even now — knowing the Denver cylinders, knowing Otto Fenn's ruined and gifted throat, knowing the carpenter's new screws in the baseboard — some frightened chamber of Cate's heart stood up at the sound of it, the way a dog stands at a whistle it has hated all its life. "You have let a clockmaker put his hands on my walls."
"Then tell me what I owe you," Cate said, steadier than she felt. She had rehearsed this. "Say it plainly, so the house can hear."
There was a pause shaped exactly like the pauses Anton used to leave at the dinner table when she had displeased him, pauses in which the whole room was required to understand that silence, from him, was a form of speech.
"You kept nothing of mine, you wrote," the voice said at last, and Pearl's hand closed hard around Cate's wrist. "Then why do I dream of a green scarf, Catherine? Of papers folded in wool, in a cedar box, under a cold floor? If you kept nothing of mine, why did you hide it so well?"
The kitchen went very quiet. Upstairs the schoolteacher from Ouray laughed in her sleep, and the wind worried at the shutters of the Alpine Rest and found them fast.
Cate stood in her own kitchen and felt the trap close, cleanly and completely, like a well-made door.