The music box had been her mother's — the one beautiful object the old woman had owned outright in a life of rented rooms: a Swiss box in a walnut case, inlaid with edelweiss, playing a waltz and a lullaby Cate could still hear her mother humming underneath like a second, softer mechanism. It had not played in nine years. It had stopped, mid-phrase, in the last winter of her mother's life, and every attempt since — by Denver jewelers and husbands in drawing rooms — had ended with the box handed back, its lid closed on the silence with an apology.
Rowan asked to see it in April and took it away without promising anything, which she had learned was his most serious form of promise. For three weeks it sat on his bench in pieces, in a drift of pinned springs and wheels no bigger than eyelashes. He would not describe the work. "It's not finished," he would say, maddeningly, and then, seeing her face: "That isn't modesty, Cate. In my trade, *not finished* is a precise condition, like *Tuesday*. When it's finished, I'll bring it up the hill."
He brought it up on the first warm evening of the year, in a basket, under a cloth, like a loaf.
They were all in the parlor after supper — the choir of the inconvenient in full residence, Otto at the piano murdering a waltz with great feeling, the Ohio girl, whose name was Willa and whose black eye had long faded, turning pages. Rowan set the box on the piano, where the lamplight could reach the edelweiss, and looked at Cate, and for a man who had faced down a court with a crate of wax, he appeared extraordinarily nervous.
"The governor was seized, and the spring had forgotten its temper," he said. "I couldn't save the spring. I made—" he cleared his throat, a man confessing to workmanship, "—I made a new one. It isn't Swiss. It's Giltspur. It may run a hundred years or it may run four; springs are honest that way, they don't lie about their intentions. The tunes are both there. I didn't touch the tunes."
He lifted the lid. He wound it once, gently, the way he set down everything that could break, and let go.
The waltz came first, thin and bright and perfect, the little steel teeth of the comb finding the tune the way fingers find a familiar stair rail in the dark — and then, as the mechanism turned over onto its second song and the lullaby began, Cate heard, rising up in her as unmistakable as a voice through a wall, her mother's humming beneath it, nine years gone, in a rented room in Leadville, keeping time over a basin and a sickbed and a daughter who had not yet married anyone, or feared anyone, or buried anyone at all. She did not cry in the butter. She cried standing up, in the middle of her own parlor, in front of her guests, without apology and without stopping the music, while Pearl's arm came around her waist like a railing and Otto, at the piano, very quietly stopped murdering the waltz and let the little box play alone.
"She kept that box through everything," Cate said at last, when the lullaby had wound down to its final, slowing notes. "Three rooms in Leadville. She pawned her wedding ring in 'eighty-one and kept the box. I never understood why."
"She kept the thing that played," Rowan said.
"Yes," Cate said. "Yes. I believe that's it, exactly." She looked at him standing beside the piano with his tradesman's hands folded and his heart, for once, entirely legible on his face, and she understood that this was his declaration — this patience, this refusal to promise what he could not finish, this new spring made in Giltspur to play a dead woman's tunes in a living woman's house — and that it was a better one than any she had ever heard spoken into a horn. "Mr. McAllister. The next time you make a spring for this house, you might consult the mistress of it first, so she can tell you she intends it to run a hundred years."
"Then I'll temper it for a hundred," he said, and the schoolteacher's sister, who had no gift for subtext, applauded, and Otto laughed aloud, and the Ohio girl turned a page of music that had already finished, for something to do with her hands.
Later, when the house had settled — the guests up the new stair, the lamp lit in the front window for whoever the night train might bring, Otto's last scales drifting down from the music room and Pearl, below, banking the stove that had eaten a ghost and thought nothing of it — Cate stood in her hall and listened to her house the way, a winter ago, she had listened to its walls in terror. It was full of voices: snores and whispers, a floorboard, a girl singing one line of a song in her sleep behind a door locked from the inside, a clock striking the true hour, on time, at last, and meaning nothing by it but the hour.
From that night on, every voice in the house was a living one, and every one of them was welcome.