Cate's hand went to the back of the judge's chair, the way a hand finds a rail on a stair in the dark. Because the house above St. Brigid's spring was the Alpine Rest, and Anton had never seen it, never known its name. Her aunt Marit had died in the spring of 1893, leaving Cate a draughty boarding house Anton had visited twice and disliked both times. In his lifetime there had been no question of Cate selling it, because it had not been hers. No cylinder recorded in Denver in 1890 could contain that question. And none could contain an *answer* to it.
The phonograph contained both.
"Tell Catherine," Anton's voice said, out of the black wax, out of three years of earth and silence, "tell her she must not sign. The spring was always mine to sell, not hers to give away. She was a good keeper of my books. Let her be a good keeper of my house, and do as she is told, for once, and keep it."
The needle ran out into hiss, and nobody in the office moved.
"Well," said Pruitt, with terrible gentleness. "You see the difficulty, Judge. Machinery does not answer questions that have not yet been asked, about a house the dead man never owned. Unless Mrs. Lindqvist's friends can explain how a dead man's voice came to know the future."
Cate looked at Rowan, the one person in the room whose knowledge she trusted more than her own fear, and what she saw on his face undid her more than the cylinder had. He was looking at the phonograph the way he looked at a clock keeping perfect time with its case nailed shut — with a craftsman's deep suspicion, and beneath it, working up like water through a crack in ice, the thing she had most dreaded seeing there.
Doubt. Not of her — she understood that even in the wreck of the moment. Doubt of his own certainty. Of the clean, human story they had carried in like a lantern: cylinders, a mimic, a diary thief, a trap sprung on a green scarf that never existed. All of it was true; she knew it was true. And yet Anton's voice had just answered a question about a house he never owned, in words shaped to the life she was living now, and the truth she knew sat in her chest beside the voice she heard, and would not, for the moment, be reconciled with it.
"Play it again," she said. "If I'm to be mad, I'd like to be mad accurately."
On the second playing she listened the way Rowan listened to everything — not for the words but for the room around them — and heard the ticking again, and, or believed she heard, a small hitch before the answer, where the voice seemed to gather itself. But she could not have sworn to it, and she did not trust unsworn things.
She walked home through the snow between Pearl and Rowan, none of them speaking for four full streets. The mantel clock announced the hour wrongly and with great confidence, and Cate stood in her hall hearing her house tick eleven minutes ahead of her life, and thought: *Perhaps I am exactly what the petition says. Perhaps the court would only be writing down what the town already believes.*
"Stop it," Pearl said, not unkindly. "I can hear you thinking it. Eat something first."
That evening Rowan came to the kitchen door with the cylinder in a padded case under his arm — Sloan, to Vera's visible fury, had ordered it held as evidence and, having no idea where a court keeps a voice, had given it to the one man in Giltspur who could be trusted not to play it for entertainment.
"Twenty-four hours," Rowan said. "Don't decide what it is until I've taken it apart. Don't decide what *you* are, either. Give the dead a day to wait, Cate. They've had three years of practice."
"And if you can't take it apart? If it's one groove?"
"Then I'll stand up at the concert and say so — and they'll still have to get past the green scarf to call you mad." He set the case down gently, the way he set down everything that could break. "But let me look properly."
She gave him the day. She slept badly and rose before dawn and made coffee she did not drink, and all day the Alpine Rest went about its ordinary music — Pearl's pans, the guests' boots, scales practiced in the front room as if the house were only a house — while across the street, behind the curtained window of the clockmaker's shop, a lamp burned steadily through the short grey afternoon and into the dark.
He came up the hill at nine that night with the case in his hands and his eyes red-rimmed and shining, and he did not wait for the door to close before he said it, in a voice that shook for the first time since she had known him: