Then the door swung, and the snow came in, and she was gone into it, and the phonograph on the platform ticked once as it cooled, settling, like any other machine when the room goes quiet.
By the first week of May, the snow had gone off the pass in patches like a quilt being unpicked, and the Alpine Rest had been, for nine days, a house in the act of becoming something it had never quite been before: itself.
Cate had spent the winter as a defendant and the spring as a carpenter. It surprised everyone except Pearl, who claimed to have known it since Cate was up a ladder in March with a mouthful of tacks, repainting the sign. The letters went back on in her own hand, in green and gold: THE ALPINE REST. Underneath, in smaller script of her own devising, a line that the schoolteacher from Ouray — now a permanent lodger, and unofficial arbiter of all the house's grammar — had protested exactly once and then defended ever after against all comers: *Board and Lodging. Music Rooms. Women Travellers Respectably Received at Any Hour.*
The "any hour" was the revolution, and like most revolutions it looked, from the street, like a lamp left burning in a front window and a kettle that never entirely left the stove. The railroad, when it finally laid its bright rails up the valley that spring, brought women through Giltspur in ones and twos — on their way to husbands, sisters, teaching posts, second chances — and once, memorably, at three in the morning, a girl of nineteen from Ohio with a carpetbag, a black eye she declined to explain, and a letter of introduction to a man who did not exist. Pearl fed her. Cate gave her the room with the good lock — the house had several good locks now, all on the insides of doors, all worked by the hands of the women sleeping behind them — and in the morning Otto Fenn, over breakfast, taught her the first line of a song her mother used to sing, which made her cry into her eggs and then laugh, in that order, which Pearl said was the correct order for everything.
Otto had stayed. That surprised the town more than the sign. In the grey weeks after the concert, while investigators asked their questions in Vera's emptied rooms, Otto had come up the hill with his one valise and stood in Cate's kitchen doorway rehearsing a speech of dismissal.
"Madame's company is dissolved. I am owed four months' wages by an enterprise that no longer exists, which is the most operatic thing that has ever happened to me, and I have been in *Faust*."
"You've come to say goodbye," Cate said.
"I've come to ask—" He stopped, searching his ruined throat for the right note. "I sang through your wall all winter, Mrs. Lindqvist. I said things no one should forgive on a first asking. I am not asking. I am saying that if the house needs a piano tuned, or a ceiling whitewashed, or a—"
"The house needs a singing master," Pearl said from the stove, in the tone of a woman settling a bill. "Half the women who'll come through here will have had their voices taken out of them one way or another, same as you had yours hired out. Board, wages when there are wages, and the back room. Sit down before you fall down; you're thin as a rumor."
He had wept then, briefly and without music, and sat down, and stayed. By May he was teaching scales to the schoolteacher's sister, harmony to a Finnish miner's widow with a voice like a church door opening, and posture — "Sing from the floor up, ladies, the floor has never once been ashamed of you" — to the rotating congregation Pearl called *the choir of the inconvenient.* If his voice still cracked on the high notes, nobody in that house confused a crack with a failure anymore. It was only a place where the light of the man's actual life got in.
The cylinders went away in April. The court released them item by item: the genuine sessions to the county archive, Vera's doctored marvel to a sealed box in Denver, where it would sit in the dark learning, at last, to keep its mouth shut. One cylinder the court returned to Cate, as *her property and no evidence in any pending matter.* It was the first one, the one that had come by post in the week the house reopened — Anton's voice reading figures and then, at the end, a scrap of unguarded nothing, recorded because Rowan's younger self had not stopped the machine in time: *"Is that the bell? Then we're done. Catherine will have kept supper."*
She kept it three weeks in the hall-table drawer, unplayed and undestroyed, and came to understand that *not playing it* was not the same as being free of it. It was only another haunting — hers, operated by hand, nightly. Anton had ruled her from a tube and from a grave and now from a drawer; the address changed, and the rule did not, and Cate, who had beaten a ghost with a diary that lied, was not going to spend her spring governed by a piece of furniture.