By Saturday, Giltspur had decided to be haunted, and was enjoying it the way it enjoyed a hanging or a wedding — as a reason to dress up and stand close together in the cold.
The posters had gone up on every board fence and storefront in town within an hour of the wagons' arrival: *MADAME KESTREL'S MARVELS. One Week Only. The Wonders of Science & Spirit, Reconciled at Last Upon One Stage. The Phonograph Speaks! The Departed Answer!* Pearl read hers aloud at breakfast with the air of a woman translating a menu in a language she mistrusted. "Reconciled," she said. "Science and spirit. In Sweden, did they allow these two to be reconciled, or did the priest come with a broom?"
"In Sweden we kept them in separate rooms," Cate said, "like relatives at Christmas."
She had not intended to go. The Alpine Rest opened on Friday to four guests and a blizzard, and a landlady's duties multiply in snow the way rabbits do in spring. But by Saturday afternoon the whole town was flowing toward the Miners' Hall as water flows downhill, and Pearl — who had opinions about everything and a curiosity that could have bored through a bank vault — put on her good shawl and announced that if the dead were going to perform in Giltspur, they would perform in front of somebody with the sense to watch the performer's hands.
Cate went, in the end, because Rowan McAllister sent a note by Tomás's boy. It was not a gallant note. It said, in a hand as precise as a gear train: *Madame K. uses three machines, I am told, and only two are on the bill. I am going to count them. Rowan M.* She folded it twice and put it in her glove, and told herself she was going as an investigator, which is the widow's permissible form of going anywhere at all.
The hall was packed to the rafters and hot as a bakehouse, three hundred people breathing steam into the lamplight. Vera Kestrel made them wait eleven minutes past the hour — Cate counted, because she had begun to count everything about the woman — and then came out alone into the gaslight in a gown of bottle green with silver at the throat, her hair dressed high and streaked with a white that no forty-seven years had put there unassisted, and stood looking at them until three hundred people had finished the extraordinary labour of becoming silent for a woman.
"Friends," she said, "I am not a medium." A murmur — disappointment and relief in equal parts. "I have never held a séance. I have never darkened a room and held hands and asked the table to knock, like a tradesman at a door. What I am is a student of the machine." She laid one hand, gently, almost tenderly, on the tall cabinet at centre stage, a thing of polished walnut shaped somewhere between a harp and a coffin stood on end. "Mr. Edison gave us an instrument that catches the voice the way a photograph catches the face. The photograph does not ask whether the sitter is living when you look at it. Why — *why* — should the voice?"
She was good. Cate, who had come to watch her hands, found herself watching her face, and was annoyed, and then was grateful for the annoyance, which was a kind of anchor. The evening unfolded like a liturgy that had learned stagecraft. There was a tenor — living, Vera insisted, smiling, as though liveness were a charming defect — though the tenor himself, a thin, pale man in evening dress, was never introduced and never spoke a word off the wax. There were band cylinders and a comedian and a child prodigy of the cornet. And then the lights were lowered to one lamp, and the cabinet was opened, and inside it, where a harp's strings should have been, stood a phonograph horn of black japanned tin, like a flower that had thought better of blooming.
"This cylinder," Vera said, into a quiet so complete that the snow could be heard, faintly, worrying at the windows, "was recorded in Leadville, in 1889, by a young man of the Confidence mine, as a Christmas gift for his mother. He sang into the horn in the morning, friends, and was carried out of that mine in the evening. His mother is in this hall tonight. She has asked — she has *begged* — to hear her son. I do not perform this wonder. I only stand aside, and let the valley of the shadow do its own singing."
What came out of the cabinet was a boy's tenor, ragged with the hiss of the wax, singing *Rock of Ages* at half the speed grief would have chosen. Halfway down the hall a woman began to cry in the particular way that is beyond embarrassment, and then the crying was general, and miners who had faced down cave-ins and company gunmen sat with their hats crushed in their hands and wept like schoolboys, and Cate understood, in her body before her mind, the size of the thing she was up against. A fraud can be argued with. This could not. This was a machine for manufacturing the one moment every grieving person on earth would pay to have back, and Vera Kestrel ran it the way Pearl ran a stove — economically, expertly, and without a flicker of waste heat on her own face.