After a while, Naomi closed the folder and set it on the step beside her, and she stood up and went upstairs to change, and Aaron followed her, and in the bedroom she peeled off the wet blouse and the soaked jeans and dropped them into the bathtub, where they lay in a dark, dripping pile, and she stood under the hot shower for a long time, letting the water run over her shoulders and down her back, washing away the cold and the smell of the garden hose and the feeling of being watched by strangers on her own lawn. When she came out, wrapped in a towel, Aaron had laid out dry clothes for her, a soft sweater and clean jeans and thick socks, and she dressed slowly, her movements careful, as if her body were still deciding whether it was safe to relax. Aaron made her tea, strong and sweet, the way she liked it when she was tired, and he brought it to her in the living room, where she sat curled in the corner of the sofa with a blanket around her shoulders, her wet hair combed back, her feet tucked beneath her, and he sat beside her, close enough that their knees touched, and he waited.
Tell me what happened, he said at last, from the beginning, slowly, all of it.
Naomi told him. She told him about the roses and the coffee and the legal folder and Evelyn's greeting and the patrol car slowing past the curb and Holt getting out and walking toward her and the way he had looked at the house before he looked at her, as if the house were the evidence and she were the intruder. She told him about the hose, about the way Holt had taken it from her hands without asking, about the cold shock of the water and the sound of it hitting the siding and the roses bending under the stream. She told him about Daniel turning off the water and apologizing, and about Evelyn calling the hospital, and about Holt asking her not to complain. She told it all in a steady voice, the voice of a woman giving testimony, and Aaron listened without interrupting, his hand resting on her knee, his eyes never leaving her face, and when she finished, he was quiet for a long time, and then he said, you did the right thing, not deciding on the lawn, not letting him rush you, not letting anger make the decision for you. But Naomi, he said, and his voice was gentle, you know what he did was not a mistake. A mistake is getting the address wrong. A mistake is knocking on the wrong door. This was a man who looked at a Black woman in front of a house worth a million dollars and decided she did not belong there, and then acted on that decision with a hose. That is not a mistake. That is a pattern. And patterns do not stop because one person decides to be polite about them.
Naomi nodded, slowly, because she knew he was right, and because she had known it from the moment Holt had said, something does not fit, although she had not heard those words herself, she had heard the echo of them in his actions. She thought about the hearing scheduled for the following week, the civil-rights appeal concerning unlawful searches and the use of police discretion during encounters with residents, and she thought about the irony of it, the terrible, precise irony, that she had been reading that record on her own lawn on the morning she became a party to the very kind of encounter the case was about. She thought about her clerk, a young woman named Sarah Kim, who would call later that afternoon, and about what she would have to tell her, and about whether she would need to recuse herself from the case or disclose the incident to the parties and let them decide whether she could still be fair. She thought about the fact that she could be fair, that she knew the law and she knew herself, but that fairness was not only a matter of what she knew in her own mind, it was a matter of what the public could see and trust, and she knew that a judge who had just been sprayed with a hose by a police officer could not simply pretend that nothing had happened and hear a case about police discretion as if she were untouched by it. The thought made her tired, a deep, bone-level tiredness that had nothing to do with the cold water and everything to do with the weight of the life she had chosen, a life in which every personal experience had to be examined for its effect on her public duty.
Her phone rang then, from the kitchen counter where she had left it, and Aaron went to fetch it, and he brought it back to her, and the screen showed the name of her clerk, Sarah Kim, and Naomi answered, her voice steady, and she listened as Sarah asked about a filing deadline and a scheduling question, and then Naomi said, Sarah, I need to tell you something, and she told her, briefly, without drama, what had happened that morning, and there was a long silence on the other end of the line, and then Sarah said, Judge Greer, are you all right, and Naomi said, I am cold and wet and my notes are ruined, but I am all right, and Sarah said, I am so sorry, and then, in the careful voice of a clerk who understood the stakes, she said, we will need to talk about the hearing next week, about disclosure, about whether you should recuse, and Naomi said, yes, we will, on Monday, in chambers, first thing, and Sarah said, I will prepare a memo, and Naomi thanked her and hung up, and she set the phone down on the sofa beside her and looked at Aaron, and Aaron looked back at her, and neither of them spoke for a moment, because there was nothing left to say that had not already been said.