When the lawyer asked him about the hose, his composure faltered for the first time. He said he had not intended to harm Naomi, and that he had picked up the hose to move it, and that the water had come on unexpectedly, and that he had lowered it as soon as he realized what was happening. He said he regretted what had happened, and that he was sorry for the distress it had caused, and that if he could go back and do it differently, he would. But when the lawyer pressed him, asking him to explain why he had aimed the hose at Naomi's face, and why he had kept it there while she stood still in the spray, and why he had ignored Daniel's voice calling his name, his answers grew thinner, and the excuses began to show through the apology like cracks in a wall.
He said he had been tired that morning, and that he had worked a long shift the night before, and that he had misread the situation. He said he had thought Naomi was a trespasser, and that he had acted on instinct, and that instinct was not always perfect. He said he had not known she was a judge, and that if he had known, he would have acted differently. Margaret Ellison leaned forward then, and asked him, in a voice that was very quiet and very clear, whether he was saying that a woman's right to stand in her own yard depended on her job title, and Holt opened his mouth, and closed it, and opened it again, and said that was not what he meant, and that he was only trying to explain that he had made a mistake.
The panel pressed him on his complaint history then, and the room listened as the lawyer read from a file that had been compiled over weeks of investigation. There were complaints from residents in other neighborhoods, complaints about stops that had lasted too long, about questions that had gone too far, about language that had made people feel small in their own streets. There were complaints that had been filed and then withdrawn, complaints that had been marked as unfounded without a full investigation, complaints that had been noted and then set aside. Holt said he did not remember some of them, and that others had been misunderstandings, and that he had never been disciplined for any of them, which was true, and which was, in its own way, the most damning thing anyone had said all day.
When the lawyer asked him whether he believed Naomi had done anything to provoke what happened, Holt said no, and when the lawyer asked him whether he believed Daniel had been wrong to write his report, Holt hesitated, and then said he believed Daniel had been young, and that young officers sometimes saw things in black and white that were more complicated than they appeared. Daniel, sitting in the front row, did not move, but Aaron, beside Naomi, felt her hand tighten briefly under the table, and then relax.
The panel deliberated for two days, and during those two days the city waited. The newspapers carried the story on their front pages, and the television stations replayed the footage, and people on Ashbury Lane left flowers on Naomi's porch, and strangers sent letters to the municipal building, and the department issued a short statement saying it was cooperating fully with the review. Inside the department, officers spoke in low voices in hallways and locker rooms, and some said Holt had gone too far, and some said he had been made an example of, and some said nothing at all, which was, in the end, the same silence that had allowed the complaints to pile up for years.
When the panel reconvened, the room was full again, and Margaret Ellison read the findings in a steady voice that did not waver. She said the panel had found that Officer Ryan Holt had engaged in misconduct, that he had used force without justification, that he had acted on the basis of an assumption about a resident's right to be in her own home, and that he had failed to follow department policy regarding de-escalation and respect for civilians. She said the panel recommended termination of his employment, and referral of the matter to the district attorney for consideration of criminal charges, and a full audit of the department's complaint process, and mandatory retraining for every officer in the division. She said the panel had also found that the department had failed in its duty to investigate earlier complaints, and that this failure had created the conditions in which the incident on Ashbury Lane could occur.
Holt sat very still as she read, his hands flat on the table, his face unreadable, and when she finished, his lawyer stood and said the union would appeal, and that Holt maintained that he had acted in good faith, and that the panel's findings were excessive. Margaret Ellison thanked him, and said the appeal process would proceed according to the rules, and that the record would speak for itself. Outside, the cameras were waiting, and the reporters were already speaking into their microphones, and the story, which had begun with a garden hose on a quiet Saturday morning, was now a matter of public record, and could not be put back into the drawer where so many other complaints had been put before it.