The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Daniel Price had become one of the people who taught inside that structure. He was twenty-six now, no longer the rookie who had sat in the passenger seat and felt the familiar discomfort of hearing his partner use language he knew was wrong, and his face had lost some of the softness it had carried when he first joined the department. He still had the same careful way of listening, the same habit of pausing before he answered, but there was a steadiness in him now that came from having made a difficult choice and having lived with it afterward. He had testified truthfully about what he saw on Ashbury Lane, he had accepted the cost of that testimony among officers who thought loyalty meant silence, and he had stayed, not because staying was easy, but because he believed the department he had joined could be made into the department he had imagined when he applied. The decree had given him a place to do that work, and the chief, a woman named Carla Mendoza who had been brought in from outside the department to oversee its reform, had given him a classroom and a mandate that was simple enough to fit on a single page. Teach rookies to check themselves before they check a resident.

On a Tuesday morning in early autumn, Daniel stood at the front of a training room on the third floor of the department's downtown building, looking out at twenty-two new recruits in dark uniforms who sat with notebooks open and pens ready, their faces a mixture of eagerness and nervousness that he remembered from his own first week. The room smelled faintly of coffee and fresh paint, and through the tall windows he could see the rain beginning to lift over the river, the clouds thinning enough to let a pale sun through. On the screen behind him was a still image from a body camera, frozen at a moment he knew by heart, and he did not turn to look at it right away. He let the recruits look at it instead, let them take in the pale yellow house, the white porch railings, the roses, the woman in faded jeans and gardening slippers kneeling beside a flower bed with a hose in her hands, and he watched their faces as they tried to decide what they were seeing. Some of them looked puzzled. Some looked as if they were waiting for him to tell them what was wrong. One young woman in the second row frowned slightly, as if she had already noticed something the others had missed.

Daniel had Naomi's permission to use the footage. He had asked her himself, in a letter he had written by hand and delivered to her house on a Sunday afternoon, because he did not want to ask through a lawyer or a department memo, and because he believed that permission for something so personal should be sought in person, or as close to in person as a letter could come. Naomi had read it twice, sitting at her kitchen table while Aaron washed dishes behind her, and then she had called Daniel and invited him to sit on her porch and talk about what he wanted to do. She had told him that she did not want the footage used as a punishment, or as a spectacle, or as a way for the department to prove to the public that it had learned its lesson by showing the worst moment of her life on a screen. She had told him that if he used it, he had to use it to teach something true, and that the truth she wanted taught was not that one officer had been wrong, but that every officer carried assumptions into every encounter, and that those assumptions, left unexamined, could become decisions before a single word was spoken. Daniel had promised her that, and he had kept the promise in every class since, which was why he stood now in front of a frozen image and said nothing for a long moment, letting the silence do some of the work.

When he finally spoke, his voice was quiet, not the loud, commanding voice some instructors used to fill a room, but the steady voice of a man who had learned that people listen more carefully when they have to lean in slightly to hear. He told the recruits that the woman in the image was a federal judge, but he told them that first, before he told them anything else, because he wanted them to understand that her title was not the reason she deserved to be treated with respect. He told them her name, Naomi Elise Greer, and he told them that she had lived on Ashbury Lane for five years, that she had planted the roses herself, that her husband was a doctor at the hospital, and that she had been reviewing a case file about unlawful searches when the patrol car slowed in front of her house. He told them that no call had come in, that no crime had been reported, that no one had asked the police to check on her, and that the only reason the car stopped was that an officer looked at a house worth almost a million dollars, looked at the woman kneeling in front of it, and decided that something did not fit. He let that phrase hang in the air for a moment, and he watched a few of the recruits shift in their seats, as if they recognized the phrase, or as if they had heard it themselves, or as if they were beginning to understand how easily a vague feeling could be mistaken for a fact.

News in the same category

The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

45 Part