The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

On Monday morning, she walked into her courtroom, and the room was fuller than usual, the benches crowded with lawyers and reporters and members of the public who had come to see what she would do. She took her seat, and she looked out at the room, and she spoke in the same steady voice she had used in the Internal Affairs office, and in the chief’s office, and in her own kitchen when she had written the complaint.

She explained that she had filed a complaint against a police officer, that the complaint involved an encounter on her own property, and that the case before the court involved questions about police discretion during encounters with residents. She said that she believed she could be fair, and that she believed the parties deserved a judge who did not carry the weight of a personal experience into the courtroom, and that for that reason, she was recusing herself, and that another judge would be assigned. She said it without anger, without self-pity, without asking the room to feel sorry for her, and when she finished, the room was silent, and then a lawyer for one of the parties stood and thanked her for her candor, and another lawyer did the same, and Naomi stood and left the bench, and the hearing was adjourned, and she walked back to her chambers and closed the door and sat down and felt, for the first time since Saturday, a kind of relief, not because the matter was over, but because she had done the honest thing, and the honest thing had been recognized.

Aaron was waiting for her at home that evening, and he had cooked dinner, a simple meal of pasta and salad, and they ate it at the kitchen table, and they did not talk about the case, or the complaint, or the news, for a long time. They talked about the hospital, about a patient Aaron had operated on that morning, about the roses, about whether the upstairs bathroom faucet would ever be fixed. And then, after the plates were cleared, Aaron reached across the table and took her hand, and he said, in the plain voice he used when he was not trying to be eloquent, that he was proud of her, and that he had always known she was strong, but that he had not known, until this week, how strong she would need to be, and that he was glad she did not have to be strong alone.

Naomi looked at him, and she thought about the five years they had lived in the yellow house, and about the note he left beside the coffee machine every Saturday, and about the way he had driven her to the police department without asking her to explain herself, and she felt the tears come, not the hot tears of anger, but the quiet tears of a woman who had held herself together for a week and who could finally, for a moment, let go.

While Naomi was finding her footing again, Ryan Holt was losing his. On the day the story appeared in the newspaper, he was placed on paid administrative leave, a phrase that sounded neutral and felt like a punishment, and he was told to surrender his badge and his weapon and to stay away from the station until further notice. He went home to a house that was suddenly too quiet, and he sat at the kitchen table, and he tried to explain to his wife, Karen, what had happened, and he found that the words did not come out in the order he wanted them to. He told her that he had been doing his job, that he had seen something that did not fit, that he had been trying to protect the neighborhood, and Karen listened, and then she asked him, in a voice that was not angry but tired, whether he had really sprayed a woman with a hose, and Holt said yes, and Karen put her head in her hands, and their teenage son, Ethan, who had been listening from the hallway, walked into the kitchen and asked his father if it was true that the woman was a judge, and Holt said yes, and Ethan said nothing, and went back to his room, and closed the door, and Holt sat there, listening to the silence, understanding for the first time that the consequences of Saturday morning would not stay at work. They would follow him home, and they would sit at his table, and they would look at him across the room, and they would ask him questions he did not know how to answer.

Holt’s past, which he had rarely thought about in any systematic way, began to press on him in the days that followed. He thought about his father, a man who had worked as a security guard in a downtown office building and who had taught his son, in a hundred small ways, to be suspicious of people who did not belong, to watch for the ones who stood out, to trust his gut. His father had not been a cruel man. He had been a frightened man, a man who had grown up in a neighborhood where strangers were a threat, and who had passed that fear on to his son as if it were a kind of wisdom. Holt had carried that fear into the police academy, and into his patrol car, and onto Ashbury Lane, and he had called it instinct, and he had been praised for it, and he had never stopped to ask whether instinct, untrained and unexamined, was anything more than prejudice with a badge.

News in the same category

The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

45 Part