The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Holt straightened, as if the request for his name had reminded him of his training, and he gave it, his voice flat, Officer Ryan Holt, badge number four-one-seven, Portland Police Bureau, and he added, almost as an afterthought, I am sorry, Dr. Greer, I made a mistake, I thought, and Aaron held up one hand, palm out, and Holt stopped. Do not tell me what you thought, Aaron said. Tell it to your supervisor. Tell it to internal affairs. Tell it to whoever reviews your body camera footage. He looked at Holt's chest, at the small black rectangle clipped to his uniform, and his eyes narrowed. Your camera, he said. Was it on?

The question hung in the air like a held breath. Holt's hand moved, almost involuntarily, toward the camera, and then stopped halfway, and his face went a shade paler than it already was. Daniel, standing a step behind him, glanced at the camera and then at Naomi, and then, in a voice so quiet that only the people closest to him could hear it, he said, it was on. It was on the whole time.

Holt turned his head toward Daniel, and for a moment the two men looked at each other, and something passed between them that Naomi could not quite name, a fracture, a line drawn in wet grass between a man who had done a thing and a man who had watched it and decided, too late but still, to tell the truth about it. Holt's mouth tightened, and he looked back at Aaron, and he tried to find a different footing, a different story. Sir, he said, I understand you are upset, and I understand this looks bad, but I was responding to a concern, I was doing my job, and I think if we can just talk about this, we can resolve it without a formal complaint, without all of this becoming something larger than it needs to be.

Naomi had been quiet while Aaron spoke, letting her husband stand between her and the officer, letting his anger be the shield for a moment while she gathered herself, but now she stepped forward, out of Aaron's arms, and she stood beside him, wet and barefoot and shivering slightly in the morning air, and she looked at Holt with the same calm she had shown from the beginning. Officer Holt, she said, you are asking me not to make a complaint. You are asking me, on my own lawn, while I am still wet from the water you sprayed on me, to agree that this does not need to become something larger. She paused, and her voice did not rise, but it grew colder, clearer, like water running over stone. I have spent my life listening to people who were asked, in rooms much smaller than this lawn, to agree that what happened to them did not need to become something larger. I have spent my life watching what happens when those requests are granted. So I will not decide this now, while I am cold and wet and angry, and I will not decide it because you are asking me not to. I will decide it as a judge and as a citizen, after I have dried off and thought clearly, and after I have spoken to my husband and my clerk. Do you understand?

Holt nodded, slowly, his hat still in his hands, his fingers worrying at the brim. Yes, ma'am, he said. I understand. I am sorry. I truly am.

Naomi did not say that she accepted his apology. She did not say that she forgave him. She turned away from him, and the turning was not dramatic, it was simply the movement of a woman who had finished a conversation and was ready to go inside her own house, and Aaron put his arm around her shoulders and walked with her toward the porch, his hand warm against her cold skin. Behind them, Daniel bent down and picked up the ceramic coffee mug from the grass, and he set it gently on the porch steps, and he looked at Naomi's wet folder and said, ma'am, I am sorry about your notes, and Naomi paused at the door and looked back at him, and for the first time since the water had stopped, her expression softened, just a fraction, just enough for Daniel to see that she had heard him and that she knew the difference between the two men standing on her lawn. Thank you, Officer Price, she said. I appreciate that.

Inside the house, the warmth wrapped around Naomi like a blanket, and she stood in the hallway for a moment, dripping onto the rug, while Aaron went to the linen closet and came back with towels, thick and dry, and he wrapped one around her shoulders and handed her another for her hair, and he knelt down and gently removed her wet slippers and set them aside, and he looked at her bare feet, red from the cold grass, and he rubbed them gently with a towel until some warmth came back into them. Naomi sat down on the bottom step of the staircase, still holding the wet folder, and she opened it again, carefully, peeling the pages apart, and she looked at her notes, at the blurred ink and the running words, and she felt tears come to her eyes then, for the first time, not because of Holt or the water or the humiliation of standing soaked in front of her neighbors, but because the notes were the product of hours of careful, honest work, and they were ruined, and she had wanted to be ready for the hearing next week, and now she would have to begin again. Aaron sat beside her on the step, and he did not try to take the folder from her, and he did not try to tell her that it did not matter, because he knew that it did matter, and he simply put his arm around her and let her look at the pages for as long as she needed to.

News in the same category

The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

45 Part