The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Chen wrote it all down, and Evelyn signed her name at the bottom of the statement in a hand that trembled slightly but did not waver, and then she walked Chen to the door and stood on her porch for a moment, looking across at Naomi’s yellow house, at the roses that were still wet from the morning rain, and she thought about the first day Naomi and Aaron had moved in, and how she had welcomed them with a plate of cookies, and how she had told Naomi that the neighborhood was a good place, and how she had believed it then, and how she still wanted to believe it now.

By the end of that week, the investigation had begun to take on a shape that Naomi recognized from her years on the bench, the shape of a story that was larger than a single incident. Lieutenant Bell’s team pulled Holt’s personnel file, and what they found inside it was not a single mistake but a pattern, laid out in dry, bureaucratic language that made the pattern harder to ignore. There were complaints, nine of them over eight years, each one filed by a resident of a wealthy neighborhood, each one describing a stop that had begun with Holt’s suspicion and ended with an apology that had never quite arrived. There was a man in a suit who had been asked for identification outside his own office building. There was a woman who had been followed for three blocks after leaving a charity gala. There was a teenager who had been stopped while walking home from a private school, his backpack searched, his phone taken, his mother called. In each case, Holt had written in his report that something did not fit, that the person had seemed out of place, that he had been acting on instinct. In each case, the complaint had been marked resolved, no discipline, no training, no note in the file that anyone had asked Holt to explain what he meant by the words he kept using.

Bell read the file twice, and then he read it a third time, and he thought about the way a department could bury a pattern by calling each incident an exception. He thought about the supervisors who had signed off on those resolutions, men who had known Holt for years, who had worked beside him, who had decided, each time, that it was easier to close a file than to open a conversation. He thought about the city’s liability, and about the chief’s promise to Naomi, and about the fact that the footage from Saturday was still, somehow, under review.

On Thursday, Bell went to Keller’s office and asked for the footage again, in person, and Keller told him, with the same respectful vagueness, that the upload was still pending, that the server had been slow, that the city’s information technology department was looking into it. Bell did not raise his voice. He took out his notebook and wrote down Keller’s words, and the time, and the date, and he asked Keller to sign the page. Keller hesitated, and then he signed it, and Bell walked out with the page in his hand, knowing that he now had a record of the delay, and that a record was the beginning of accountability.

The same day, a reporter named Jessica Morales from the local newspaper called the department’s public information office and asked about a complaint filed by a federal judge. She had heard about it from a source she would not name, a clerk in the courthouse who had seen Naomi leave the Internal Affairs office with a folder under her arm, and who had mentioned it to a friend, who had mentioned it to Morales. Morales asked the questions that reporters ask, calmly and persistently, and the public information officer gave her the answers that public information officers give, which were mostly variations on the phrase no comment, but Morales had been a reporter for twelve years, and she knew that no comment was itself a kind of answer.

She called Naomi that evening, and Naomi did not give her an interview. She told Morales, politely, that she had filed a complaint and that she trusted the process, and that she would not be commenting further. Morales thanked her and hung up, and then she called Evelyn Porter, and Evelyn, who had never spoken to a reporter in her life, told her what she had seen, because she believed that the truth did not belong only to the people who had filed the paperwork. The next morning, the story appeared on the newspaper’s website, under a headline that was careful and factual, and by noon it had been shared thousands of times, and by evening it was on the local television news, and by the following morning it was being discussed on national programs, and Naomi, sitting at her kitchen table with Aaron, watched her own name move across the screen and felt a strange distance from it, as if the woman in the story were someone else, someone she had read about in a case file, not someone who had stood barefoot on her own lawn, soaked to the skin, while a man with a badge held a hose in his hand.

The attention brought with it a new pressure. Colleagues called her, some to offer support, some to warn her that a judge who filed a complaint against the police would be seen as having taken a side, that her impartiality would be questioned, that the civil-rights hearing she was scheduled to preside over the following week would now be impossible for her to hear. Naomi listened to each call, thanked each caller, and said very little, because she had already made the decision that those callers were urging her to consider. She would recuse herself from the hearing, not because she had done anything wrong, but because the appearance of fairness mattered as much as fairness itself, and because a judge who had just been the victim of the very kind of encounter at the heart of the case could not pretend that the encounter had not happened.

News in the same category

The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

45 Part