The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The outside review did not arrive like a storm. It arrived like a tide, slow at first, then impossible to hold back, and by the time the people of Portland understood what was happening, the water was already at the doors of the precinct on Ashbury Lane and far beyond it. Naomi Elise Greer watched it come from the one place she had always trusted most, which was the law itself, and she watched it with the same careful attention she gave to a record on appeal, reading every page, weighing every claim, refusing to let anger do the work that evidence was supposed to do. The review had been ordered after the hearing in which Chief Delgado admitted that the silence went higher than Officer Ryan Holt, and the men and women appointed to conduct it were not from Portland. They came from other cities, other departments, other courtrooms, and they carried with them a reputation for patience, which was another way of saying that they did not hurry toward the conclusion everyone already expected. They asked for files. They asked for recordings. They asked for emails, for memos, for the handwritten notes that supervisors kept in desk drawers and believed no one would ever read. They interviewed officers one by one, in rooms without windows, and they asked the same questions in different ways until the answers stopped changing. What they found, when the first report was finally released, was not a single bad officer. It was a pattern, and a pattern is always harder to look at than a single man, because a pattern means that many people knew, and many people chose, day after day, to do nothing.

The report began with the complaints. There had been forty-one of them over nine years, filed by residents of Laurelhurst and the neighborhoods around it, and by people who had been stopped on streets where they lived, in driveways where they parked, on porches where they sat with their own coffee. Most of the complaints had been written in the careful language of people who were afraid of being dismissed, and most of them had been dismissed. The reviewers read them aloud in their summary, not by name, but by fact, and the facts repeated themselves with a rhythm that made Naomi close her eyes for a moment when Aaron read the summary to her at the kitchen table. A woman asked for identification while watering her own garden. A man asked to prove that the car in his own driveway belonged to him. A teenager asked to empty his pockets on the sidewalk outside his own house. A nurse, coming home from a night shift, asked to explain why she was walking in her own neighborhood at four in the morning. In each case, the officer had written that the person had seemed out of place, or that the property had seemed inconsistent with the person, or that something had not fit, and in each case, a supervisor had signed the bottom of the report and filed it away. The reviewers found that twenty-seven of the forty-one complaints had never been investigated at all. Nine had been investigated by the same supervisor who had signed the original report. Five had been closed with a single sentence, insufficient evidence, written in the same handwriting, in the same ink, on the same kind of form, as if the words had been stamped rather than thought.

Naomi sat with that number for a long time. Twenty-seven. She thought of the roses on Ashbury Lane, and of Evelyn Porter, who had lived there for more than fifty years and had watched the neighborhood change, and she thought of all the people who had filed a complaint because they believed, as she had believed, that the system would listen if you spoke clearly enough. She thought of the courage it took to write your name on a form and hand it to the very department you were complaining about, and she thought of what it must have felt like to hear nothing back, to wait for a letter that never came, to understand, slowly, that your words had been placed in a drawer and forgotten. Aaron put his hand over hers, and neither of them spoke, because there was nothing useful to say about a number like that, except that it had to change, and that change would have to be built, piece by piece, by people who were willing to stay with the work long after the cameras left.

The second part of the report was about the supervisors. The reviewers named two of them, and Naomi knew both names from the record, though she had never met either man in person. The first was Lieutenant Marcus Webb, who had supervised Holt for six years, and who had signed off on eleven of the dismissed complaints. Webb had not merely failed to investigate. He had, according to the emails the reviewers recovered, actively discouraged investigation, writing to other supervisors that certain complaints were not worth the paperwork, and that certain neighborhoods generated more complaints because certain residents were more sensitive. In one email, written after a complaint from a Black homeowner on a street not far from Ashbury Lane, Webb had written that the resident should be grateful the officer had been polite. Naomi read that sentence three times, and each time it seemed worse, because politeness had never been the question. The question had always been whether a person had the right to stand in her own yard without being treated as a trespasser, and whether a badge gave an officer the right to decide, on the basis of a glance, that she did not belong there. Webb resigned the week the report was released. He did not give a press conference. He did not apologize. He sent a letter, two paragraphs long, in which he said that he had served the department for twenty-four years and that he believed it was time for new leadership. The letter did not mention the complaints. It did not mention the residents. It did not mention Naomi. Aaron read it aloud, and Naomi listened, and then she folded the newspaper and put it aside, because a resignation that does not name what it is resigning from is not an apology. It is an exit.

News in the same category

The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

45 Part