The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The second supervisor was Sergeant Daniel Kline, a man whose name had appeared in the record only in passing, but who, the reviewers discovered, had played a larger role than anyone had understood. Kline had been the department's informal trainer for new officers, the man who taught them how to write reports, how to describe an encounter, how to choose words that would protect them if a complaint was ever filed. He had coached officers, the report said, on wording, and the wording he coached them to use was always the same. Seemed out of place. Appeared inconsistent with the surroundings. Did not fit the property. The reviewers found notes from his training sessions, written in his own hand, in which he had told a room full of young officers that if they wrote that a person had seemed nervous, no one would question them, and that if they wrote that a person had been uncooperative, the complaint would almost always be dismissed. He had taught them, in other words, not how to see more clearly, but how to describe what they had seen in a way that could not be challenged. Kline was demoted, not fired, and the demotion was announced in a short statement that said he would be reassigned to administrative duties and would no longer train officers. Naomi thought about that, too. She thought about all the young officers who had sat in his classroom and learned that language, and she thought about Daniel Price, who had sat in a patrol car with Holt and had heard that language used in real time, and who had known, even then, that something was wrong with it. She thought about how long it takes to unlearn a way of speaking, and how much longer it takes to unlearn a way of seeing, and she understood that the demotion of one sergeant would not undo the years in which his words had shaped the department. It was a beginning, not an ending, and beginnings, she had learned, are always quieter than endings, and always harder to sustain.

The third part of the report was about the missing footage. The reviewers had asked for body camera recordings from every case in which a complaint had been filed, and in fourteen cases, the footage was missing. In some cases, the camera had been turned off. In others, it had never been turned on. In three cases, the footage had existed, and then it had been lost, and the explanation for the loss was a single line in a logbook, file corrupted, written in handwriting that the reviewers could not match to any officer on duty that day. Naomi thought of Holt's own camera, which had been on that morning on Ashbury Lane, and which had captured the water from her own garden hose arcing through the air, and her own voice, steady, asking him to stop, and his voice, loud, telling her to stay where she was. She thought of how different the story might have been if that camera had been off, if there had been no recording, if it had been only her word against his, and she felt a coldness in her chest that had nothing to do with the rain that morning. The reviewers recommended a new policy, one that would require cameras to be on during every encounter with a member of the public, and that would make the failure to activate a camera a disciplinary offense in itself, not an excuse to be explained away later. The chief accepted the recommendation the same day, and Naomi, reading the announcement, allowed herself a small, careful hope, because a policy is only words on paper until someone enforces it, but words on paper are where enforcement has to begin.

The federal inquiry opened two weeks after the report was released. It was announced in a brief statement from the United States Attorney's office, and it said that the Department of Justice would examine whether the Portland Police Bureau had engaged in a pattern of civil rights violations, and whether the department's leadership had failed to address that pattern. Naomi read the statement twice, and then she put it down, because she knew what a federal inquiry meant, and she knew what it did not mean. It meant that investigators would come, that they would ask questions, that they would subpoena records, and that the process would take months, perhaps years. It did not mean that justice would arrive quickly, or that it would arrive in a form that anyone could predict. It meant, instead, that the story of Ashbury Lane was no longer only Naomi's story. It belonged, now, to every person who had filed a complaint and been ignored, to every officer who had tried to speak and been silenced, to every resident who had learned to be careful on their own street. Naomi felt the weight of that, and she felt, too, a responsibility that she had not asked for but could not refuse, which was to be careful with her own words, to speak about the law and not about herself, and to remember that a judge who becomes a symbol can too easily stop being a judge.

News in the same category

The Officer Sprayed A Black Woman With Her Own Garden Hose — Then He Saw Her Badge

45 Part