She folded the pages into the folder and carried it to the car, and Aaron drove her, because she did not want to arrive at the police department alone and she did not want to arrive in a taxi, and because there was something steadying about sitting in the passenger seat while someone she trusted handled the road. Portland in the early morning was gray and damp, the streets still wet from the rain that had fallen overnight, and the roses on Ashbury Lane were far behind them now, but Naomi could still feel the water on her skin when she thought about it, a cold memory that returned whenever she closed her eyes.
The police department’s Internal Affairs office was on the third floor of a concrete building downtown, a place with fluorescent lights and thin carpet and a receptionist who looked up with a practiced neutrality when Naomi gave her name. Naomi asked to file a formal complaint against an officer, and the receptionist’s expression did not change, but her hand moved a little faster across the keyboard, and she asked Naomi to wait. A lieutenant named Marcus Bell came out to meet them, a man in his late forties with a shaved head and a calm manner, and he shook Naomi’s hand and Aaron’s hand and led them into a small interview room with a table and four chairs and a recorder on the table that he switched on after asking permission.
Naomi told the story again, slowly, in the same order she had written it, and Lieutenant Bell listened without interrupting, his pen moving across a notepad, his eyes on her face. When she finished he asked her a series of questions, each one precise, each one designed to fix a detail in place. What time had the patrol car first passed the house. How long had Holt stood on the lawn before he picked up the hose. How far away had Daniel Price been standing. Had Holt identified himself before he used the hose. Had she said anything that could have been interpreted as a threat. Naomi answered each question in the same steady voice, and Aaron sat beside her, silent, his hands folded on the table, watching Bell the way a surgeon watches a colleague who is about to make an incision, waiting to see if the hands are steady.
When the interview was over, Bell told her that the complaint would be logged and that an investigator would be assigned, and that she would be contacted within five business days. He said it in the tone of a man who had said the same words many times before, and Naomi heard the rehearsal in it, the smooth edges worn down by repetition. She asked him, politely, whether the body camera footage from Holt’s and Price’s cameras would be preserved, and Bell said that all footage was automatically preserved, and that she need not worry about that. Naomi nodded, but she wrote the date and the time of the conversation in her notebook before she left the building, and she wrote down Bell’s name and rank, and the name of the receptionist, because she had learned long ago that a record made in the moment was worth more than a memory reconstructed later.
She did not go home after that. She went to the chief’s office, because a complaint filed with Internal Affairs could sit in a drawer for weeks, and because she knew, from twenty years on the bench, that a matter moved faster when the person at the top had been told about it in person. Chief Laura Whitfield was a woman in her late fifties, with silver hair and a reputation for blunt honesty, and she listened to Naomi with her hands folded and her eyes narrowed, and when Naomi finished, Whitfield did not offer sympathy. She offered a question.
“Do you want me to handle this as a complaint, Judge Greer, or do you want me to handle this as a test of whether this department can police itself?”
Naomi looked at her for a long moment.
“I want you to handle it as both,” she said.
Whitfield nodded, once, and stood up, and walked to the window, and looked out at the street below, where a patrol car was pulling away from the curb.
“I will request the footage today,” she said. “And I will expect it on my desk by tomorrow morning.”
But by tomorrow morning, the footage had not arrived. The sergeant who supervised Holt’s shift, a man named Tom Keller, told the chief’s office that the footage was under review, that there were technical issues, that the upload from Holt’s camera had been delayed. He said it in a voice that was respectful and vague at the same time, the voice of a man who had learned to say a great deal while committing to very little. Whitfield asked him to put that in writing. Keller said he would, and then he did not, and when Whitfield’s assistant called him again that afternoon, Keller said the footage was being reviewed by the city attorney’s office, which was not true, and which Whitfield discovered when she called the city attorney herself and was told that no one there had seen it.
Naomi learned about the delay from a phone call that evening, and she sat at the kitchen table with the phone in her hand for a long time after she hung up, listening to the refrigerator hum, thinking about the way a system protected itself. She had seen it in courtrooms, in cases where a record went missing, where a witness suddenly could not remember, where a document was produced a day late and a dollar short. She had always believed that the law was a tool for prying open closed doors, but she had also learned that a door could be held shut by a dozen small hands, each one pushing only a little, each one able to say, truthfully, that it had not closed the door alone.