The Truth Beneath the Silver Paint

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Both things could not be true in the way I had always understood them. The photograph said my mother died eighteen years ago, three days after October 14. My memory said my mother was alive when I was ten, sewing a dress for me in the workroom. And there was a third thing, too, something I had heard all my life and never examined: that my mother had died eight years ago, when I was ten. Eight years, the family story said in one breath. Eighteen years, the photograph said in another. I had grown up hearing both, and I had never put them side by side until that afternoon in her bedroom.

I did not try to resolve them. I did not throw the photograph away, and I did not doubt my memory. I sat down on the edge of my mother's bed and I held the photograph in both hands, and I looked at her face for a long time. She was smiling. Her hand was on her belly. Vanessa's hand was on her arm. Whatever the dates meant, whatever the years added up to, this much was true: my mother had loved the child she was carrying, and she had trusted the woman standing beside her, and she had written the date on the back of the photograph in her own hand.

I took my notebook out of my bag and I wrote down everything, exactly as I found it. The photograph, dated October 14, eighteen years ago. The family story, that it was taken three days before my mother's death. My memory, of my mother sewing for me when I was ten. The other story, that she died eight years ago. I wrote them all down, one after another, without choosing between them, without crossing any of them out. Then I put the photograph back in its envelope and I put the envelope in my bag, and I went downstairs to the workroom, and I stood at the cutting table where my mother had sewn that blue dress for me when I was ten, and I put my hands flat on the wood, and I stayed there until the light went out of the windows.

I did not know what the dates meant. I only knew that the photograph was real, and my memory was real, and the numbers did not fit together, and I was going to keep them both until I understood why.

Daniel took me to the records office three days after I found the photograph. He had filed a request for the birth records, and the clerk brought out two files in grey folders, and laid them on the counter between us, and I opened the first one with hands that would not stop shaking.

My own birth certificate was on top. Amelia Hart. Born October 17, eighteen years ago. Mother: Vanessa Hart, née Sinclair. Father: Thomas Sinclair. I read the names twice, and then I opened the second folder, and there was the other certificate, and the date on it was the same. October 17, eighteen years ago. Lily Sinclair. Mother: Vanessa Hart, née Sinclair. The same mother. The same day.

The word twins was written across both certificates in the same hand, in the margin, as if the clerk who had filled them out had wanted there to be no doubt. Two girls, born on the same day, to the same mother. Twins, the records said. My twin sister was Lily Sinclair, and I had stood on a stage with her and never known it, and I had watched her from across a crowded room all my life without understanding what she was to me.

I stared at the two certificates lying side by side on the counter, and I thought about Lily. I thought about her face, which was so like my own in some lights and so unlike it in others, and I thought about the way she had always kept her distance from me, as if there were a wall between us that neither of us had built. I thought about Vanessa, who was her mother and my mother, and who had raised neither of us as a mother should, and I thought about the house we had all lived in, full of secrets that had been kept so long they had begun to feel like walls.

Daniel pointed to the line on Lily's certificate where the father's name should have been. There was a stamp across it, and the word amended, and beneath the stamp the writing was smudged, as if someone had tried to change it and then thought better of it, or as if the change had been made in a hurry and never properly finished. "We will need the full file for this one," Daniel said. "The amended record is held separately. I have already requested it."

I nodded, but I was barely listening. I was looking at the date. October 17. Three days after the photograph. October 14, my mother smiling in the garden with her hand on her belly. October 17, two girls born. And the family story said my mother died three days after the photograph was taken. Three days after October 14 was October 17. The day the girls were born was the day, the story said, that my mother died.

News in the same category

The Truth Beneath the Silver Paint

45 Part