The Truth Beneath the Silver Paint

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Lily Sinclair was eighteen, like me. She was Vanessa's daughter. The records said she was my twin sister, same mother, different father, and the two of us had been born on the seventeenth of October, eighteen years ago, in the same hospital, on the same day, three days after the photograph of Catherine had been taken.

I had never met her. I had never known she existed until the file gave her a name. Vanessa had a daughter, and the daughter had a name, and the name was Lily, and Lily was my sister, and I had lived eighteen years in the same city as my own twin sister and never once laid eyes on her.

The records did not agree about everything. The birth record said Vanessa had been twenty-four when Lily was born. The caption written on the back of the photograph said twenty-five. I put the two papers side by side on Daniel's desk and looked at them for a long time, and neither one of them changed. I did not try to make them agree. I had learned by then that the papers in this family did not agree with each other, and that trying to force them to agree was how the lies had been hidden in the first place.

The amended record was the paper that stopped me cold. Someone had gone back to Lily's birth record and changed it. The amendment was typed on a separate sheet and clipped to the original, and it named Lily's father. The name on the amendment was Richard Hart.

I read that name and felt the floor tilt. Richard Hart was my adoptive father. He was the man who had raised me, the man whose name I carried, the man who had sat in the audience on the night of the competition and watched me walk down the aisle in a ruined dress with my mother's flowers sewn onto it. The amended record said he was Lily's father. It did not say he was mine. My own record named Thomas Sinclair as my father, and Thomas Sinclair had been dead for eighteen years, or so the world had believed.

I asked Daniel who had filed the amendment. He said the filing stamp was dated, and the date was six months after Catherine's death, and the signature on the filing was Vanessa's. Six months after Catherine died, Vanessa had signed a transfer of four hundred and eighty thousand dollars, and she had also filed an amendment naming Richard Hart as the father of her daughter. Two papers, one hand, one season. I did not know what she had meant by either of them. I knew only that she had been busy in those six months, remaking the record of our family while the rest of us were still grieving.

I met Lily in Daniel's office, because neither of us had a place that felt safe enough for it. She came in holding her bag in front of her like a shield, and she looked at me the way you look at a stranger who is wearing your face. We had the same eyes. I had seen my eyes in the mirror every morning of my life, and now I saw them looking back at me from across a room, set in a face I had never seen before.

She told me what Vanessa had told her, which was almost nothing. Vanessa had told her that she had a sister once, and that the sister had gone to live with another family, and that it was better not to ask questions about it. Lily had asked questions anyway, when she was small, and Vanessa had stopped answering them, and after a while Lily had stopped asking. She had grown up knowing she had a sister the way you know a room in your house is locked: you know it is there, and you know you are not supposed to open it, and after a while you stop thinking about the door.

She asked me if Catherine had been kind. I told her Catherine had been the kindest person I had ever known, and that she had sewn me dresses and taught me to cut fabric and had named a design house after her own name and mine. Lily listened with her hands folded in her lap, and when I finished she said, very quietly, that she was glad one of us had been loved like that.

I told her about the amended record. I told her the paper named Richard Hart as her father. She was quiet for a long time, and then she said that Vanessa had never told her who her father was, and that she had stopped asking about that, too. She said she had always assumed it was a man who had gone away before she was old enough to remember him, and that the name Richard Hart meant nothing to her beyond the fact that it was the name of the man who had been married to her mother.

News in the same category

The Truth Beneath the Silver Paint

45 Part