Daniel did not tell me gently. He told me the way he told me everything, with the papers laid out in a row and the facts stated plainly, as if plainness could make them easier to carry. A man named Thomas Sinclair had been found living two counties away, under his own name, working with his hands and keeping to himself. He had a scar on his forehead from a car accident eighteen years ago, and he had a letter from Catherine Lane in a drawer, and he had waited eighteen years for someone to come and ask him who he was.
I did not believe it at first. I had spent my whole life believing my father was a dead man, and the dead do not come back because a lawyer finds their name in a file. I told Daniel there had to be a mistake. He said there was a blood test, and the blood test did not make mistakes, and the blood test said Thomas Sinclair was my father. He said the same test said he was Sophie Hart's father, too. He did not say anything about Lily. The papers about Lily said something else, and I had already learned not to ask the papers to agree.
I met him in a small room in Daniel's office, because that was the only place any of us felt safe anymore. He came in alone, and he stood in the doorway for a moment, and he looked at me the way Lily had looked at me, like a stranger wearing a face he knew. He had my eyes. I had seen my eyes in the mirror every morning of my life, and now I saw them in the face of a man I had believed was dead.
He told me about the accident. The car had gone off the road on a wet night, and he had woken in a hospital with a broken head and no memory of how he had got there, and by the time he understood what had happened, the papers already said he was dead. His sister had signed them. His sister had arranged the funeral, or said she had. His sister had told the world he was gone, and the world had believed her, because Vanessa had always been very good at making the world believe what she told it.
He told me he had tried, once, to come back. He had written to Catherine, and Catherine had written back, and her letter was the one he kept in his drawer, the letter that said she knew who he was, and that she knew whose child I was, and that she would keep me safe, and that he should stay away until the time was right. He had believed her. He had stayed away for eighteen years, working with his hands and keeping to himself, because the woman who had raised his daughter had asked him to, and because he had nothing to fight Richard with and no one who would believe a dead man.
I listened to him, and I believed him, and I did not believe him, both at once. He was my father, and he was a stranger. He had been dead for eighteen years, and he was sitting across from me, alive, with my eyes and a scar on his forehead and a letter from my mother in his drawer. I asked him if he had known about the money. He said he had known Vanessa and Richard were taking it, and that he had told Catherine, and that Catherine had been the one who hid the records. I asked him if he had known about the medicine. He said he had not known, and that he wished he had, and that he had carried that wish for eighteen years.
When he left, I sat in Daniel's office for a long time, alone with the papers. My father had been dead for eighteen years. My father was alive. Both of those sentences were true, and I had learned by then that in my family, two true sentences could contradict each other and still both be true. I wrote his name in my notebook, under Vanessa's name, and I drew a line between them, and I wrote the word brother beside it, and then I wrote the word father beside my own name, and I looked at the page for a long time before I closed the notebook and went home.
Thomas Sinclair was the father of Amelia and Sophie. That was what the papers said, in one place, and what Thomas himself said, and what Catherine's letter said, and what the blood test said. Thomas Sinclair was the father of all three of us. That was what the papers said, in another place, all three, Amelia and Lily and Sophie, daughters of one man, sisters by blood as well as by paper.