I went to see Sophie Bennett in the back of the workshop, where she still sat at her machine, hemming a dress that would be worn by a woman she would never meet. She did not stop sewing when I came in. She kept the machine going with her foot, steady as a heartbeat, and she talked to me without looking up, as if the words would come easier if her eyes stayed on the work.
She told me she had been a seamstress with little money and long hours, and that a baby had needed more than she could give it, and that Peter Bennett had been a good man who had wanted a child and had none, and that the arrangement had been made quietly, between people who understood each other, and that she had gone back to her machine the next morning and sewn as if nothing had happened. She said the rent did not stop for grief. She said the dresses did not stop needing hems. She said she had told herself the child would be better off, and that she had believed it, and that believing it had been the only way she could keep sewing.
I asked her about the silver ribbon. She stopped the machine then. Her foot came off the pedal, and the needle stopped in the middle of a stitch, and she sat very still with her hands in her lap, looking at them as if they belonged to someone else. She said the ribbon had been hers. She said it had been a scrap from her sewing box, a length of silver ribbon she had kept for a special occasion, and that she had tied it around her baby's wrist on the day she gave her up, so that the child would carry something of her mother's with her into her new life. She said she had tied it in a small bow, neatly, because she had wanted it to look like a gift, and not like a goodbye.
I asked her if the baby in the photograph was her daughter. She said she did not know. She said the photograph could have been her daughter, or it could have been a twin, and that the papers said both things, and that she had never seen the photograph before I showed it to her. She said the ribbon in the photograph looked like her ribbon, and that the bow looked like the bow she had tied, and that she could not be sure, after eighteen years, whether she was remembering the ribbon or remembering the wish that the ribbon had been hers.
Peter Bennett came to the workshop that evening, because Sophie had sent for him, and he stood in the doorway with his cap in his hands and told me he had raised Sophie Hart from the day she was brought to him, and that he had loved her from that day, and that he had never asked whose child she had been, because the child had been his from the moment he held her. He said he did not care what the papers said about blood. He said blood was what ran in a body, and love was what raised a child, and that he had raised Sophie Hart, and that no paper in the world could take that away from him.
I believed him. I believed Sophie Bennett, too, with her hands in her lap and her machine stopped in the middle of a stitch. I believed that a seamstress had given her daughter a silver ribbon and a new father, and that she had gone back to her machine the next morning and kept sewing, because the rent did not stop for grief, and because the dresses did not stop needing hems, and because sometimes the only thing a mother can do for her child is to give her away to someone who can do more.
When I left the workshop, I carried the photograph with me, and I thought about the ribbon, and about the two notes that did not agree, and about the seamstress who had tied a bow around her baby's wrist so that the child would carry something of her mother's with her. The baby with the silver ribbon was Sophie Bennett's child, the papers said, in one place. The baby with the silver ribbon was a twin, the papers said, in another. I did not know which one was true. I knew only that a woman had tied a ribbon around a baby's wrist eighteen years ago, and that the ribbon had been silver, and that silver was the colour of the truth in this family, and that the truth, like the ribbon, was still there, waiting to be seen.
Catherine's wedding ring had hidden a note. I had known that since Daniel showed me the ring in the locker, and I had carried the knowledge with me for days without opening it, because some part of me understood that once I read my mother's words, there would be no going back to not knowing them. The ring was small and plain, and the note inside it was folded smaller still, and it took me a long time, with a pin from Catherine's sewing box, to work it open without tearing it.