I thought about the night I was born, and the three Sophies arranged around it like points on a map: the nurse who was there, the seamstress who was giving a child away that same season, and the daughter who was still a baby herself, being carried out of one life and into another. None of them had chosen the name. The name had chosen them, and then it had hidden them, one behind the other, for eighteen years.
When I finished the labels, I sat back and looked at the three folders in a row. Three women. One name. And the name, for the first time, could not hide any of them anymore.
Among the papers Daniel gave me, there was a photograph I had never seen before. It was a hospital photograph, the kind they take in the nursery in the first hours, when the baby is wrapped tight and sleeping and the world has not yet had its say. The baby in the photograph had a silver ribbon tied around her wrist. The ribbon was thin and bright, and it caught the light even in the photograph, and it was the first thing my eye went to, before the small face or the wrapped blanket or the date stamped in the corner.
The date in the corner was the seventeenth of October, eighteen years ago. The day Lily and I were born.
There were two notes with the photograph, and they did not agree. The first note, written on the back of the photograph in a hand I did not know, said the baby was a twin. The second note, clipped to the photograph and written in a different hand, said the baby was Sophie Bennett's child, and not a twin at all.
I held the photograph under Daniel's lamp and looked at the ribbon until my eyes hurt. A silver ribbon, tied around a baby's wrist. Someone had tied it there on purpose. Someone had wanted that baby marked, or remembered, or found again. A ribbon is not an accident. A ribbon is a choice, made by hands that knew what they were doing, and the hands that had tied this one had tied it neatly, in a small bow, as if the baby were a gift someone meant to come back for.
I thought about the silver paint. Silver had followed me through this whole story, the paint poured over my dress, the ribbon tied around a baby's wrist, the colour of a thing that shines and stains at the same time. The paint had ruined my dress and saved it, both at once, because the ruined dress was the one I walked onto the stage in, and the stage was where I held up the envelope. The ribbon had marked a baby and hidden her, both at once, because the mark was the only thing that said which baby she was, and the papers could not agree on what the mark meant.
I asked Daniel which note was right. He said he did not know, and that the two notes had come from two different files, and that both files had been kept by people who believed what they had written. He said the hospital record named two babies born that night to one mother, and that the seamstress's file named one baby given up that same season, and that the silver ribbon appeared in both stories, and that he could not make the two stories into one without choosing which paper to believe and which to throw away. He would not do that, he said. And neither would I.
I put the photograph back in its sleeve and slipped the two notes in after it, one on each side, so that neither of them would be on top. The baby with the silver ribbon was a twin, the papers said, in one place. The baby with the silver ribbon was Sophie Bennett's child, the papers said, in another. I did not know which baby the ribbon belonged to. I did not know if the ribbon had been tied by a mother who meant to come back, or by a nurse who wanted the baby found, or by a seamstress who had nothing else to give her daughter but a scrap from her sewing box. I knew only that the ribbon was silver, and that silver was the colour of the truth in this family: bright, and hard to wash off, and impossible to ignore once you had seen it.
I kept the photograph where I could see it while I worked. Every time I looked at it, I remembered that the truth did not always come in one piece, and that sometimes it came in two pieces that did not fit, and that my job was not to force them together. My job was to carry them both, and to let the court see them both, and to let the truth be what it was, even when it was two things at once.
Thomas Sinclair was Vanessa's brother. He was my father. He had been dead for eighteen years, killed in a car accident on a wet road the year I was born, and his name was on a death certificate, and his sister had mourned him, or said she had, and the world had gone on without him. And then Daniel Reeves told me he was alive.