And then there was the amended record. The amendment clipped to Lily's birth record, filed six months after Catherine's death, signed by Vanessa, naming Richard Hart as Lily's father.
I laid the three papers on Daniel's desk and looked at them until the words blurred. Thomas, father of Amelia and Sophie. Thomas, father of all three. Richard, father of Lily. Three papers, three fathers, and only three girls between them. The arithmetic did not work, and I had stopped expecting it to work, because the arithmetic of my family had never worked, and the people who had made the papers had counted on no one ever doing the sums.
I thought about Richard. Richard Hart was the man who had raised me. He was the man whose name I carried, the man who had sat at the head of our table and signed the school forms and paid the bills and stood in the audience on the night of the competition and watched me walk down the aisle in a ruined dress. He was my adoptive father, and he had been my father in every way that mattered when I was small, and he had also been the man who forged signatures and stole money and switched my mother's medicine. Both of those men were Richard Hart. I had loved one of them and I feared the other, and they were the same man, and I had to hold both of them in my head at the same time, the way I had to hold everything else in this family.
I thought about Thomas. Thomas was the man who had made me, and the man who had stayed away for eighteen years because Catherine had asked him to, and the man who had kept her letter in a drawer and waited. He had not raised me. He had not taught me to cut fabric or to thread a needle or to stand straight when the room was watching. Catherine had done those things. But he was my father, and his blood was in me, and the blood test said so, and the letter said so, and his own mouth said so, and I believed all three.
And I thought about Lily. Lily, who had grown up with Vanessa as her mother and no father at all, until the amended record gave her one. Lily, whose paper named Richard, and whose blood, if the other paper was right, named Thomas. Lily, who had sat across from me in Daniel's office and told me she had stopped asking who her father was. I did not know which paper was true for Lily. I knew only that the amendment had been filed by the same hand that had signed the transfer, in the same season, six months after Catherine died, and that Vanessa had been remaking our family on paper while the rest of us were still learning how to grieve.
I did not choose between the papers. I wrote down what each one said, in my notebook, in three separate lines, and I did not draw any lines between them. Thomas, father of Amelia and Sophie. Thomas, father of all three. Richard, father of Lily. Three lines, three truths, and a family that would not fit into any one of them.
That night I stood in Catherine's workshop and looked at the cutting table where she had taught me to work, and I thought about what a father was. A father was the man who raised you, and the man who made you, and the man the papers named, and sometimes those three men were the same man, and sometimes they were three different men, and sometimes you had to live with all three at once. I had three sisters, or two sisters, or one sister twice over, depending on which paper you read. I had three fathers, or two, or one, depending on which paper you read. The papers did not agree, and I had stopped asking them to. I would take them all to court, and I would let the court read them, and I would tell the truth about what each one said, and that would have to be enough.
Sophie Bennett sewed for Catherine's design house. I had seen her hands a hundred times, quick, sure hands, the kind that could take a flat piece of cloth and make it stand up and hold a shape, the kind that knew where the fabric wanted to go before the scissors did. I had never thought to ask what those hands had held before they held a needle. I had never thought to ask what they had given up.
Sophie Bennett was the mother of Sophie Hart. She had carried the child for nine months and given birth to her in the same season Lily and I were born, and then she had given her daughter away. Peter Bennett had taken the child as his own. He had signed the papers, and he had given the girl his name, and he had raised her as his daughter, and he had never once, in eighteen years, told her she was anything other than his.