They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

Chapter 1

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

At 2:36 on a warm Saturday afternoon, Simone Harper sat in a folding chair at the edge of Bellmont University’s campus lake with a fishing rod balanced between both hands.

Simone was twenty years old, Black, a junior majoring in environmental biology, with long braids pulled behind her shoulders, a fitted white tank beneath a black leather jacket, black jeans, and dark boots already muddy from the shoreline. A clear plastic holding tub filled with lake water and several freshly caught fish rested on the grass beside her as part of an approved fisheries-sampling exercise she planned to finish before meeting her research partner.

The tub had a laminated card taped to the side, because Professor Ramsey required a laminated card on everything that held a living animal. BELLMONT AQUATIC ECOLOGY — PERMIT 2214 — TEMPORARY HOLDING — DO NOT DISTURB. Simone had printed it herself in the lab three weeks earlier and had laughed at how official it looked, and had thought, briefly and without any particular feeling, that nobody on this campus had ever needed a laminated card to be left alone.

The afternoon was the kind that made the brochure photographers come out. Seventy-nine degrees. A low wind off the water. The willows on the north bank moving in that slow underwater way willows have. Two kayaks a quarter mile out, barely moving, their paddlers more interested in talking than in going anywhere. The smell of cut grass from the maintenance mowing that had finished an hour before, and under it the green mineral smell of the lake itself, which Simone had decided during her first month at Bellmont was the single best thing about the place.

She had been on the bank since 12:50. She had four fish in the tub: three bluegill and a largemouth bass just over fourteen inches, which she had been quietly pleased about and had photographed with a ruler for the log. She needed two more bluegill for the size-distribution set. She had her field notebook open on her knee with a pencil tucked into the spiral, and she had written, at 2:31, in her small square handwriting:

1431 — wind SSW light. Surface temp 21.4. Four held. Bass 35.6 cm, released after measurement at 1450 per protocol. Waiting on #5–6.

She was watching the line when two white students approached from behind, laughing quietly enough that she never turned around.

The brunette walking closest to Simone was Madison Vale, a twenty-one-year-old junior wearing a black racing-style jacket over a white cropped shirt, loose denim shorts, striped socks, and sneakers, with sunglasses resting on top of her head. Beside her was Chloe Barrett, a blonde twenty-year-old in an oversized tie-dye sweatshirt, short olive skirt, high socks, and white sneakers.

They had not come to the lake looking for Simone. That detail would matter later, in a hearing room, when somebody tried very hard to make it matter in the opposite direction. They had come because Chloe wanted photographs for a post and the willows were good at four o’clock, and they had been walking the shoreline path for eleven minutes before Madison saw the folding chair and the braids and the tub and stopped walking.

Chloe would testify that Madison stopped for about four seconds.

Four seconds is a long time, when you watch it on video. It is long enough to be a decision.

Madison glanced at Chloe, smiled, then lifted one foot behind Simone’s folding chair.

Without warning, she drove her sneaker hard into the back of the chair and Simone’s lower body.

The chair folded sideways as Simone pitched toward the water with the fishing rod still in her hands. She hit the lake chest-first, disappeared beneath a wall of muddy spray, and surfaced several feet from shore while the chair floated awkwardly behind her.

What the clip does not capture, because no clip captures this, is the three seconds Simone spent underwater.

She told a counselor about it four months later and said it was the part she still woke up from. Not the fall. The three seconds. The lake bottom at that part of the bank is silt over clay, and her boots went into it past the ankle, and for three full seconds she could not tell which way was up because the water was brown and her braids had wrapped across her face and the only thing she was certain of was that something was holding her feet.

She was an excellent swimmer. She had been swimming since she was six. None of that is available to you in the first three seconds of being in water you did not choose to enter.

She got a foot free. She got the other foot free. She came up.

Madison and Chloe stood on the bank laughing as Simone struggled to plant her feet in the soft bottom. Neither girl moved to help.

Chloe was filming. She started filming about a second and a half after the kick, which meant her video began with Simone already in the water, and which meant that for the next nine days the only widely seen footage of the afternoon started at the moment that made Simone look like a woman who had simply fallen in.

By the time Simone reached the bank, her braids were dripping, her leather jacket clung heavily to her shoulders, and water poured from her jeans into the grass. The rod was still in her right hand. She had not let go of it. Her grandfather had given her that rod when she was eleven, and letting go of it had never once occurred to her, not in three seconds of brown water, not ever.

Madison looked at her soaked clothes and made another comment that caused Chloe to laugh even harder, while Simone stared at both women in disbelief.

The comment, recovered later from a different recording, was: “Oh my God, she matches the lake now.”

Simone demanded to know what was wrong with them and asked whether pushing someone into a lake was supposed to be funny.

Madison answered with the same phrase she had been using for months.

“Relax. It was a joke.”

Simone could have walked away then, and later she would wish she had done exactly that.

She would say so, out loud, in a room with a recording device, with her mother sitting behind her: I should have walked. I want that written down. I had a phone in a dry bag and a dean’s office that had already warned her once and a folder with eleven months of screenshots in it, and I had every tool a person could want, and I didn’t use any of them, and that’s on me.

Instead, she stayed, because Madison had moved toward the transparent fish tub, looking down at the animals swimming inside as though she had discovered another prop for the performance.

Simone warned her not to touch the container because the fish were part of an ecology project and would be measured before release.

She said it the way you say something to a person you still believe might stop. Flat. Almost polite. “Don’t touch that. Those are permitted animals. They’re going back in the water in twenty minutes.”

Madison smiled, lifted one sneaker, and kicked the entire tub onto its side.

The lid flipped open and water rushed across the grass. Several fish slid out with it, thrashing beside the overturned container while Simone immediately crouched toward them.

There is a specific sound a fish makes on grass. It is not a loud sound. It is a sort of wet slapping, irregular, and it stops and starts, and there is nothing in the world that makes a biologist move faster.

Madison looked down at the mess and made a remark about Simone being able to “catch dinner again,” while Chloe laughed behind her.

That was when Simone’s anger finally overtook the judgment she had spent the entire semester trying to preserve.

She stood and confronted Madison at close range.

Madison continued smiling.

And Simone struck her first, sending her stumbling sideways toward the overturned tub.

Simone would later admit without qualification that this was retaliation rather than self-defense, because Madison was no longer physically attacking her at the exact second Simone swung. Her attorney would wince every time she said it. She would keep saying it.

What happened after that, however, was captured just as clearly.

Chloe immediately rushed toward Simone and began swinging. Simone ducked the first strike, raised both arms against the next, and moved backward while Chloe kept coming at her. After several attempts to create distance, Simone started countering, using short strikes and pushes whenever Chloe closed the space between them.

News in the same category

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

20 Part