They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“Nothing changed,” Simone said. “I just have more left over now. That’s all it is. That’s all any of it ever is.”

Nobody has ever satisfactorily explained the four seconds.

That is the gap at the center of this, and it will stay a gap, because the only person who can close it has said nothing since the nineteenth of June and will probably say nothing ever.

Here is what is known.

Madison Vale and Chloe Barrett had been walking the shoreline path for eleven minutes. They were taking photographs. They had come from the Wellington Society’s end-of-year brunch, where Madison had eaten very little and had argued with a friend about something unrelated that two witnesses later described as “a seating thing.”

They had not discussed Simone that day. Chloe was clear on that in her statement, and her statement on this point was against her own interest, which is generally when statements are worth something.

Madison saw the chair.

She stopped for approximately four seconds.

Then she kicked it.

The hearing panel, which had the benefit of all the evidence and no obligation to speculate, declined to speculate. Angela Soto-Whitfield, whose job was to analyze institutional failure rather than individual psychology, also declined, and said so explicitly in a footnote: The reviewer makes no finding as to the respondent’s motive and considers the question outside the scope of this review.

Everybody else speculated enormously.

The most popular theory was the summer position, and it has the appeal of a clean motive: Madison applied, Madison lost, Madison asked the professor twice whether race was the reason, Madison was told no twice, and Madison carried that for six weeks until she saw the person who got it sitting alone by a lake.

It is plausible. It may even be right.

The problem with it is the timeline. The position was announced on the eleventh of March. The lake was on the twenty-sixth of April. In between there are six weeks with no documented incidents at all, which is either six weeks of nothing or six weeks of something, and nobody can say which.

The second theory is simpler and is the one Lena Cho believes.

“There’s no reason,” Lena said. “That’s the thing people can’t accept. Everyone wants it to be about the fellowship or the summer thing or her family or whatever, because then it’s a story. I was around her for two years. She did stuff like that constantly, at a smaller scale, to a lot of people, and almost all of it was just — available. Somebody was in a position where she could do something and get a laugh, and so she did.

“The reason it was Simone over and over wasn’t a grudge. It’s that Simone was alone a lot and carried weird equipment and didn’t laugh along. If you don’t laugh along you become a target, and if you’re also the only Black girl in the room your not-laughing reads as attitude instead of as a person not thinking something is funny. That’s it. That’s the whole engine. It isn’t deep. People want it to be deep.”

The third theory is the one Simone has.

She was asked directly, once, and gave an answer that nobody who asked it wanted.

“I don’t have one,” she said. “I spent nine months trying to figure out what she had against me and the thing I finally landed on is that trying to figure it out was the harm. That’s where it actually got me. Not the jokes. The nine months of lying in bed building theories about a person who wasn’t thinking about me at all when she wasn’t in the room.

“Whatever was going on in her head, I was never going to get it. And every hour I spent trying was an hour she got for free.”

The Harpers did not sue the university.

They were advised, by two firms, that they had a strong claim — not for the harassment, which is hard, but for the interim suspension, which was imposed on the basis of a thirty-one-second video and a respondent statement while an exculpatory incident report sat unread in the institution’s own system.

Denise Harper, who is an accountant and who understands exactly what money is, was in favor of it for about three weeks.

Calvin was opposed from the beginning.

Simone was the one who decided, and she decided in July, at the field station, over the phone, standing outside a bunkhouse with mosquitoes on her arms.

“If we sue,” she said, “then for the next three years every single time somebody says my name the next word is lawsuit. And I will be a plaintiff before I’m a scientist for the entire beginning of my career. I’m not doing it.”

Denise said, “They should pay something.”

“They are paying something,” Simone said. “They’re paying Soto-Whitfield two hundred thousand dollars to write down everything they did wrong and then publish it, and that document is going to exist forever and every university lawyer in the country is going to read it. That’s worth more than a settlement I’d have to sign a confidentiality clause for.”

There was a long silence on the line.

“When did you get like this?” her mother said.

“May,” Simone said.

Chloe Barrett came back in January and finished her degree.

It took her three additional semesters because she had lost credits, and she lived off campus the entire time, and she changed her major from communications to social work.

People have made a great deal of that change, in both directions — as proof of transformation, as proof of performance. Both readings are cheap.

What is documented is this: she completed the restorative process, which the facilitator described in a closing memo as “engaged, often defensive in early sessions, substantively different by session six.” She wrote the required reflection, which is confidential. She requested a facilitated conversation four times and was declined four times and, per the facilitator, accepted the fourth refusal without complaint and did not ask again.

And she did one thing nobody required.

In her final semester she sat for a two-hour recorded interview with Angela Soto-Whitfield’s office — not for the review, which was long finished, but for a training module the university was building for incoming students.

She agreed to have her name used.

Her attorney advised against it in writing.

News in the same category

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

20 Part