They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

Chapter 11

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He said, “What time?”

They told him.

Hollis Dunn put down a sandwich, walked out to a utility truck, drove the service road to the south shore, climbed a ladder he kept in the bed, pulled the card out of the camera, drove back, put the card in the reader on the office computer that the grounds department used for ordering, and scrolled.

There were four hundred and eleven files on the card.

Forty-one of them were from that Saturday.

He found what he was looking for in about ninety seconds, because the timestamps are burned into the corner of the frame, and because he is a man who has spent twenty-six years finding things.

He watched it twice.

Then he sat in a metal folding chair in a grounds office that smelled like two-stroke fuel, with a sandwich going stale on the desk, and said, out loud, to nobody, “Oh, you have got to be kidding me.”

Then he called his supervisor.

His supervisor called facilities.

Facilities called the general counsel’s office, because by that point everything at Bellmont was calling the general counsel’s office.

And at 4:40 p.m. on the tenth day, a sixty-two-year-old groundskeeper who had never met Simone Harper sat in a conference room with three attorneys and an associate dean and played a three-second clip that changed the entire direction of an institution.

The trail camera clip is three seconds long.

It is 1920 by 1080, shot from one hundred and ninety feet across open water, slightly soft, with a timestamp in the lower right corner reading 04/26 14:36:11.

In it, you can see a folding chair at the edge of the bank with a seated figure in dark clothing. You can see a clear tub on the grass. You can see two figures walk into frame from the right and stop behind the chair.

You can see one of them lift a leg.

You can see the chair go over.

And then the clip ends, because the clip is three seconds.

By itself, it is not quite enough. A hostile attorney could argue about resolution, about angle, about whether contact can be definitively established at that distance.

But the camera does not take one clip.

It takes a clip, then a still, then it rearms, and if motion continues it fires again.

Between 14:36:11 and 14:39:02 it fired eleven times.

Eleven clips. Eleven stills. Two minutes and fifty-one seconds of coverage, with gaps, from a fixed angle, with timestamps.

Clip four shows Simone in the water and two figures standing on the bank, not moving.

Clip six shows Simone on the bank and one figure stepping toward the tub.

Still seven — a single frame, 14:37:44 — shows the tub on its side and a dark spreading shape on the grass where the water went.

Clip eight is the one.

Clip eight runs 14:37:49 to 14:37:52, and in it, the figure in the light-colored top steps forward and extends a leg at ground level, and the tub, which is stationary in the first frame, is on its side by the last frame.

Nobody was going to argue about clip eight.

Hollis Dunn’s card was the beginning, and over the following six days four more pieces came in, each from a direction nobody had planned.

The second was the GoPro.

Professor Ramsey’s lab had a protocol, adopted three years earlier after a dispute about handling times in a published dataset, that any undergraduate conducting fisheries sampling alone must record the handling portion of the work. Not for surveillance. For animal-welfare documentation — to demonstrate that specimens were held within permitted durations and returned alive.

Simone had a small camera clipped to the strap of her tackle bag.

It had been running since 1:04 p.m.

It had been pointed, for most of that time, at the tub.

Nobody thought of it for ten days. Not Simone, who had been in the water and then had been fighting and then had been holding a fish and then had been suspended and driven three hours north; not Ramsey, who had been consumed with memos; not Campus Safety, who had no reason to know the protocol existed.

Lena Cho thought of it.

She thought of it on day eleven, at two in the morning, sitting up in bed, and she said out loud in a dark dorm room, “Oh my God, the welfare cam.”

She called Ramsey at 7:05 a.m. He was in the lab by 7:20. The tackle bag was in the equipment room where Campus Safety had deposited Simone’s belongings, inside a labeled evidence bag that had never been opened because nobody had told anybody to open it.

The camera had sixty-eight minutes of recording and about nine percent battery left.

The audio is the part that mattered.

News in the same category

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

20 Part