They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Simone has never watched it.

She has said she knows what it sounds like.

What the first wave did to her, in order, over nine days:

Day one. Four hundred messages. She read most of them. She said later this was the stupidest thing she did in the entire affair and that she would tell anyone in the same position to hand the phone to someone else before they open it, and that nobody ever does.

Day two. A man emailed her university address — her university address, which is firstname.lastname and is therefore guessable — and described what he hoped would happen to her. She forwarded it to Campus Safety. Campus Safety forwarded it to the general counsel. The general counsel’s office forwarded it to a law firm. Nobody replied to Simone for eleven days.

Day three. Somebody posted her parents’ street. Not the number. The street.

Calvin Harper, who had taught high-school history for twenty-two years and had never done anything about anything on the internet in his life, drove to the hardware store and bought two motion lights and a doorbell camera and installed them himself on a Tuesday afternoon, and did not tell his daughter, and she found out eight months later and sat down on the stairs.

Day four. The counter-wave started — people defending her, which was better and was also its own weather. Accounts with six-figure followings began posting about the case with total confidence and zero information. One of them asserted that Madison had used a slur. She had not. That claim was repeated approximately two hundred thousand times and was still being repeated a year later, and the fact that it was false made every true thing harder to say, which is always what happens and which almost nobody factors in while they are doing it.

Day five. Her high school’s alumni page posted about her, supportively, and the comments under it went exactly as you would expect in both directions.

Day six. She stopped eating properly. Denise noticed on day seven.

Day seven. Lena’s thread. The first time anybody with any proximity to the facts said anything in public.

Simone read it in bed at two in the morning and cried for twenty minutes, which she described later as the first good crying of the nine days, and then texted Lena: you didn’t have to do that

Lena replied: i did tho

Day eight. Teresa Obi’s first email, which Simone did not answer for six days because she had decided she was never speaking to a reporter.

Day nine. Nothing. Day nine was a Monday and nothing happened at all, and Simone said that was somehow the worst one, because by then she had organized her entire nervous system around the expectation of impact, and the absence of impact felt like the pause before it.

The trail camera surfaced on day ten.

There is a thing that people who have been through this describe and that people who have not been through it consistently fail to anticipate, and Simone described it better than most.

It is that being publicly defended does not undo being publicly attacked. They do not cancel. They stack.

“Everyone thinks the relief comes when the truth gets out,” she said. “It doesn’t. What comes is more. More messages, more notifications, more strangers with extremely strong feelings about my life, and now a lot of them love me, which sounds nice and is not, because they love a version of me that is about four percent accurate and they are going to be very disappointed in the real one.

“The first wave, people wanted me to be a monster. The second wave, people wanted me to be a saint. The thing I actually am is a twenty-year-old who got kicked in a lake and then made a bad decision in three seconds, and there was no wave for that, because that’s not content.”

One more thing about the nine days.

On day six, somebody found Madison Vale’s younger brother.

He was sixteen. He was a sophomore at a private high school in Northern Virginia. He had never met Simone Harper and had nothing to do with anything.

Within about four hours there were photographs of him circulating with his school’s name on them, and by the following Monday he was not attending that school, and he did not go back that year.

Simone found out about this in June, from her own attorney, in the context of preparing for the hearing.

She asked what had happened to him.

Her attorney said it wasn’t relevant to the hearing.

Simone said, “I didn’t ask if it was relevant.”

She thought about that kid a great deal. She has said so, publicly, more than once, and every time she has said it some portion of her supporters have been actively annoyed with her, and she has kept saying it.

“They did it in my name,” she said. “Nobody asked me. And I understand that I don’t get to control a crowd, I’m not an idiot. But there’s this thing where people want you to be the victim so completely that you’re not allowed to notice anybody else getting hurt, because noticing complicates the story. And I was there. I’m the one person in this whole thing who was actually at the lake. I’m allowed to notice.”

She was asked whether she had ever considered saying anything about it publicly at the time.

“I wrote something,” she said. “Twice.”

“Did you post it?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

A long pause.

“Because on day six I was a person who had been suspended from her university and had four hundred people a day telling her she was an animal,” she said. “And I didn’t have it in me to spend what little I had left defending the brother of the girl who did it. I wish I’d had it. I didn’t.”

“Would you now?”

“Yes.”

“What changed?”

News in the same category

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

20 Part