She said no.
She was asked again in December, after Chloe’s facilitator reported that Chloe had asked about it four times.
She said no again.
She said, to her mother, on the phone: “I am not responsible for the inside of that girl’s head and I am not spending an hour of my life helping her feel better about the worst thing she’s ever done. If that makes me small, fine. I’d rather be small than be a service.”
Denise said, “That doesn’t make you small.”
“It feels like it does.”
“That’s not the same thing.”
In February, Chloe sent a letter.
Not through the facilitator. Through the mail, to the department, in a sealed envelope with Simone Harper on the front, which the department administrator held for four days while she figured out whether she was allowed to pass it on, and then passed on, because there was no policy about letters.
It was two pages, handwritten.
Simone has never released it and has said she never will. She has described it, once, in six words.
“It was about her, mostly. Mostly.”
She was asked whether there was any part of it that was not about Chloe.
“One paragraph,” she said. “The last one.”
She did not say what was in it.
She also did not throw the letter away.
Lena Cho graduated the following spring and went to law school.
She has said, flatly and repeatedly, that she did not do anything brave and that she is uncomfortable with being told she did.
“I posted a thread with eighty-three followers nine days after it happened,” she said. “Nine days. Do you understand what nine days is? She was in her mother’s house with the blinds down for nine days while I thought about whether posting would make my life complicated. I was the only person in that major who knew the whole thing and I waited nine days.”
Pressed, she added:
“And I’d told Madison the joke was old, one time, in a lab, in November. One time. And I felt great about it for about six months. That’s the part I’d like people to understand. I was the good one. I was the good one and I was useless for eight months, and if you’re reading this and you think you’d have been better, you’re probably the good one too.”
Professor Elliot Ramsey took a leave of absence for the spring semester.
He came back in the fall. He is still there. He teaches the same seminar.
He added one thing to it. On the first day of every semester, before the syllabus, he spends eleven minutes on a document that is not about aquatic ecology.
It is page 63 of the Soto-Whitfield report — the section about March, about the conversation in his office, about fatigue and misjudgment and a plaque two hundred yards away.
He reads his own paragraph out loud.
Then he says, every time, in the same words:
“I am the most senior person in this room and I had every form of power that exists in a university and I did not write down four sentences. I want you to understand that the failure in this story is not located in some department you will never work in. It is located in a man who was tired on a Thursday.”
Students have described this as the single most uncomfortable eleven minutes of their undergraduate education.
Enrollment in the seminar has gone up every year since.
Hollis Dunn retired two years later, at sixty-four.
He was given a plaque, which he found funny for reasons he did not explain to the people who gave it to him.
Teresa Obi tried to interview him three times. He declined three times, politely, and on the third occasion said the only thing he has ever said publicly about any of it:
“I put a camera on a tree to catch a fella dumping grass clippings. That’s the whole story on my end. Everything after that was just the card being full.”
He still has the bobcat photograph.
He does not have a copy of clip eight. He was offered one and said no.
Simone Harper graduated with a 3.79, which is lower than the 3.81 she carried into that April, and she will tell you the difference is one grade in one course in one semester and that she does not care, and she will tell you that in a tone that makes clear she has thought about those two hundredths of a point more than she would like.
She went to graduate school at a public university in the Midwest, in fisheries science, on a research assistantship.