They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

Chapter 18

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The reason it does not end there is that nothing about the nine months was decided in that room. The room processed what had already happened. It processed it reasonably well, by the standards of such rooms, which is not a high bar and which is not nothing either.

What decided the nine months happened in ordinary rooms, in ordinary minutes, by people who were not doing anything unusual.

A dean who closed a file because the box was empty.

A professor who was tired on a Thursday and wrote a question about selection criteria instead of what was actually said.

A communications office that produced a summary on a Monday morning from the only two documents that happened to be in the system on a weekend.

A staff member who wrote a walk-in note in a spiral book nineteen months before any of it, and filed the book, and did exactly what she had been trained to do.

A twenty-year-old who said “it’s not worth it, her family’s on a building.”

A girl with eighty-three followers who waited nine days.

And a groundskeeper who put a camera on a tree because somebody was dumping grass clippings.

Of all of those people, only one of them did anything that was not standard practice, and he did it fourteen months earlier, for an unrelated reason, and he did not register it.

That is the finding under the finding, and Angela Soto-Whitfield put it in the executive summary in a single line that the university’s general counsel tried twice to have softened:

This institution did not fail at the moment of crisis. It performed its ordinary procedures competently and arrived at an outcome that was nearly catastrophic for an innocent student, and would have been catastrophic but for evidence that existed by accident.

A process whose correct operation depends on luck is not a process. It is a hope with paperwork.

Simone spent that summer in Maryland, at the field station, in waders, up to her thighs in the Chesapeake watershed, exactly as planned.

Ramsey had fought for it. There had been a view in one corner of the administration that it would be better for everyone if the summer position were deferred a year “given the circumstances,” which is the kind of sentence that gets said in rooms by people who believe they are being thoughtful.

Ramsey’s email on that subject was two sentences and it circulated inside the department for years afterward:

The circumstances are that a student was assaulted and then suspended for it by this university. If your proposal is that she also lose the position she earned, I would like that proposal in writing with your name on it.

Nobody put it in writing.

She left for the station on the ninth of June, three days before the hearing, and drove back for the hearing, and drove straight back afterward, eleven hours of driving in two days, and was in the water at 6:40 the next morning.

The field station was four hours from anything. There were nine people there. There was no reliable cell signal.

She has said, in the only long interview she has ever given, that the summer saved her, and that she does not mean that as a figure of speech.

“I was in bad shape in May,” she said. “I want to be honest about that because I think people hear a story like this and they picture somebody who was strong the whole time, and I wasn’t. I was having panic attacks in a car in a parking lot. And then I went to a place where nine people knew me as the person who could run the shocker, and for eleven weeks nobody asked me a single question about a lake.”

She caught twelve thousand four hundred and some fish that summer.

She counted them, because that was the job.

Three of them were species that had not been recorded at that site in the eleven years of the dataset.

Her name is on the paper. Third author. It came out eighteen months later in a journal with an impact factor nobody outside the field has heard of, and she has a printed copy, and it is the thing on the wall of her apartment, and the other thing is not on the wall of her apartment.

Walter Harper died in April of the year before she transferred, which means he never saw Bellmont and never knew that any of this happened.

Simone has said she is glad.

She has also said, in the same breath, in the same interview, that there has not been a week since the lake when she has not wanted to call him, and that the specific thing she wants to tell him is not about Madison Vale or the video or the hearing.

It is that she held the third fish for four and a half minutes and it did not go.

“He’d have known what to say about that,” she said. “Nobody else does. Everybody wants to tell me it wasn’t my fault, which — I know. I know that. That’s not what I’m asking. I’m telling you I had something alive in my hands and I did everything right and it still didn’t work, and I’m twenty-one and I don’t have anywhere to put that.”

The interviewer asked what she thought he would have said.

Simone thought for a while.

“He’d have said, ‘How long did you hold it?’ And I’d say four and a half minutes. And he’d say, ‘Well, then.’”

“That’s it?”

“That’s it. ‘Well, then.’” She laughed a little. “You’d have to have known him.”

Chloe Barrett came back in January.

She had served her semester. She had completed the restorative process, which at Bellmont meant eight sessions with a trained facilitator, a written reflection, and — if and only if the harmed party consented — a facilitated conversation.

Simone was asked, in October, whether she consented.

News in the same category

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

20 Part