Teresa Obi emailed Lena Cho at 11:48 p.m. Wednesday.
Lena replied at 11:51, which tells you what kind of week Lena was also having.
Thursday. Chloe Barrett deleted her account.
She did it at 2:15 in the afternoon, after four days of being tagged in things, after her own phone number appeared somewhere, after a stranger sent a message to her mother’s business page in Charlotte.
This is the part of the story that nobody enjoys and that has to be in it anyway: the people who went after Chloe Barrett that week were not doing justice. They were doing the same thing Chloe had done, at scale, with the same equipment, and feeling excellent about it.
Simone said so, later, publicly, at considerable cost to her popularity with people who had appointed themselves her defenders.
Friday. Bellmont’s president issued a second statement. It was longer and said less. It used the phrase we are gathering all available information, which is a phrase that means we did not gather all available information before our first statement and are hoping you do not notice.
Simone, by then, was in her childhood bedroom in Catonsville, three hours north, with the blinds down.
She had not spoken to anyone at the university since Monday except Dean Bell’s assistant, who had called to confirm receipt of her room key.
She was not sleeping. She was doing something that resembled sleeping for forty minutes at a time, four or five times a day, and in between she was lying on her back looking at a ceiling she had looked at as a child, and the thing she kept returning to was not the suspension or the video or the comments.
It was the third fish.
Four and a half minutes with her hands in the water.
She told her father about it on Friday night, in the kitchen, at one in the morning, both of them standing up, neither of them eating the food in front of them.
“I keep thinking I should have been faster,” she said.
Calvin said, “Honey, you put your hands in a lake for five minutes trying to make a bluegill breathe.”
“It was four and a half.”
“Simone.”
“I know. I know how it sounds.” She pressed her palms against her eyes, the same gesture Dev Rao had photographed eleven days — six days, then — earlier. “It’s just the only part of the whole thing I could have done anything about.”
Calvin Harper taught high-school history for twenty-two years and had developed a specific, unshowy talent for not filling silences.
He let that one sit.
Then he said: “Walter would have stood there four and a half minutes too.”
And Simone made a noise and sat down on the kitchen floor with her back against the dishwasher, and her father sat down next to her, on the floor, at one in the morning, a fifty-four-year-old man in a bathrobe with bad knees, and neither of them said anything else for a long time.
Saturday. One week.
Teresa Obi drove to Bellmont and spent six hours on campus and talked to nineteen people.
She found four things that day, and any one of them would have been a story.
The first was Officer Ron Petrie’s incident report, which she obtained because she asked Petrie for it directly and Petrie, who had worked there nineteen years and had never once been asked for anything by a reporter, said, “You’ll have to go through the office, but I’ll tell you right now they’ve had it since Sunday.”
The report contained the sentence: Student H. stated unprompted that she struck first and that the other party was not physically engaged with her at that moment.
And, four lines later: Student H. also stated that the incident began when she was kicked from behind into the lake and that her research specimens were deliberately overturned. Two uninvolved witnesses on the path, interviewed separately, independently described a kick to the chair prior to entry into the water.
Two witnesses. Interviewed Saturday. Both described the kick.
The report had been in the system since Monday morning.
The second thing Teresa Obi found was that the groundskeeping department had a camera.
It was not a security camera. Nobody had installed it to watch anybody.
It was a trail camera — the kind hunters strap to trees — mounted eleven feet up a sycamore on the south shore of the lake, pointed northwest, with a motion trigger and an infrared flash and a 32-gigabyte card.
It had been placed there fourteen months earlier by a groundskeeper named Hollis Dunn, who was sixty-two, had worked at Bellmont for twenty-six years, and had put it up because somebody had been dumping yard waste at the lake edge on weekends and he wanted to know who.
He had caught the yard-waste guy in about three weeks. A contractor. It got handled.
He had left the camera up because he liked it. It took pictures of herons. It had taken a picture of a bobcat in January that he had printed at a drugstore and taped inside his locker.
The camera fired on motion. It took a three-second video clip and then a still, with a timestamp burned into the corner.
It was pointed, from a distance of about one hundred and ninety feet, across the water at the west bank.
At the folding chair.
Hollis Dunn did not know about the video. He did not use social media. He found out on the following Tuesday, ten days after the incident, when two of the grounds crew were talking about it over lunch and one of them said the name Bellmont and the word lake and the word fight.
He said, “What day?”
They told him.