They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The module is eighteen minutes. It is shown to every incoming Bellmont student during orientation. Chloe is in it for about four minutes, and she does not cry, and she does not ask for anything, and the part everybody remembers is near the end when the interviewer asks her what she would tell a first-year student who is standing next to someone who is doing something cruel.

And Chloe Barrett says:

“Everybody thinks the question is whether you’d stop them. That’s not the question. I’ve watched that video of myself about a thousand times and I know exactly what I did, and I want to be precise about it, because people keep letting me off easy by calling me a bystander.

“I wasn’t a bystander. I had my phone up before it happened. I said ‘don’t’ — I did, you can hear it, and for a while that was the thing I held onto, like it proved something about me. It doesn’t prove anything. I said ‘don’t’ and I kept filming and then I laughed, and then I cut the first four seconds off the video so that people would see the part where she looked bad.

“That took me about forty minutes to decide to do. Forty minutes. That’s not a reflex. That’s not getting caught up in a moment. I sat in my room and I thought about it and I made a choice, and the choice was that I’d rather a person I’d never had a conversation with get destroyed than have anyone look at Madison that way.

“So don’t ask me about stopping her. Ask yourself what you’d do in the forty minutes afterward. That’s where I actually did the worst thing, and nobody ever asks about that part, and it’s the only part I had all the time in the world to get right.”

After the external review was published, eleven other students contacted the conduct office.

Nine were current. Two had graduated.

None of them had been kicked into a lake. That is the point of them.

The office logged each contact and, because the new respondent index existed by then, the entries sat together on one screen for the first time, and what they formed was not a series of incidents but a shape.

A sophomore described being asked, during her first week on campus, whether her scholarship was “the athletic one,” which was notable because she did not play a sport.

A junior described a two-month period in which someone had repeatedly moved his belongings in a shared studio space and left them in the hallway.

A graduate student described a conversation at a department social in which Madison Vale had asked, in front of four people, how international students afforded the program.

A senior described nothing specific at all, and said so, and said she had come in anyway because she had read the report and recognized the February entry about the protected-characteristic box and had sat down on her bed and thought, that happened to me too and I never even reported it because I knew what the question would be.

That last one is the one Dean Bell kept.

He printed it. He has it in a drawer. He has told exactly two people this.

Marcus Bell was not disciplined.

The review found that he had acted within policy at every point, which was both true and the worst thing it could have said about him, and he understood that perfectly well.

He requested a meeting with Simone in late September, after the report came out. He routed the request through Ramsey, because he did not want her to feel that a dean was summoning her, and Ramsey asked her, and she thought about it for four days and said yes.

They met in a coffee shop off campus, which was Bell’s suggestion and which Simone appreciated more than she expected to.

He did not bring anything. No folder, no notes, no institutional object of any kind.

He said: “I’m not here to ask you for anything and I’m not going to ask you how you’re doing, because you’ve had about nine hundred people ask you that and I don’t have a right to the answer.”

Simone said, “Okay.”

“I’ve read my own section of that report about thirty times,” Bell said. “There’s a sentence in it I can’t get past. Page fifty-eight. ‘The most significant failure in the timeline.’ That’s me. February eleventh. That’s my meeting and my form and my question.”

“You asked the question the form made you ask.”

“I know you’ve said that publicly.” He turned his cup around on the table. “I want to tell you why that’s generous and wrong, and then I’ll stop talking about it.

“The form made me ask the question. The form did not make me stop. I had thirty-one documented items in front of me in November and a follow-up in February, and when the box came back empty I closed it, and I closed it because a closed file is a resolved file and I have four hundred of them a year and resolved is the only thing anyone measures me on.

“Nobody at this university has ever once asked me how many open files I’m carrying. They ask how many I’ve closed. And I knew that, and I’d known it for eleven years, and I’d built my whole professional self around being the guy who clears the queue.”

Simone did not say anything for a while.

Then she said: “What do you want me to do with that?”

“Nothing.” Bell actually laughed, briefly, without much in it. “That’s what I mean about not asking you for anything. I’m not looking for absolution. I’m telling you because you spent nine months being the only person who could see the whole thing, and I think you’ve earned one administrator saying out loud what he actually did, instead of what the policy permitted.”

They talked for forty more minutes about other things. About the field station. About his daughter, who was applying to colleges and who wanted to study marine biology, and about whom he asked Simone three questions he clearly had been saving.

At the end, standing outside, he said one more thing.

“The pattern question on the new intake form. ‘Has the reporting party described more than one incident involving the same respondent.’”

“I saw it.”

“I wrote it,” he said. “In August. In about nine seconds. It took nine seconds to write and it would have changed everything, and it had never occurred to me in eleven years, and I need you to understand that I’m not telling you that as a good thing I did.”

Simone looked at him.

“I know,” she said. “I know what you’re telling me.”

There is a version of this story that ends at the hearing, with the finding and the suspension, and a lot of people would have preferred it.

News in the same category

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

20 Part