They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She did not cry. She noted, with a kind of clinical detachment that frightened her a little, that she was not crying, and that what she felt instead was the specific exhaustion of understanding that a thing she had hoped was in her head was not in her head.

She showed it to Denise during a phone call that night.

Her mother asked whether Simone believed Madison was targeting her because she was Black.

Simone said she did not know.

She said it honestly. She said, “Mom, she’s never said anything. Not one thing you could point at. I don’t know if she’s like this with everybody and I’m just the one who notices.”

Denise was quiet for a moment. Then she answered:

“You don’t have to decide what is in her heart before you decide her behavior is a problem.”

Simone stayed quiet.

That distinction helped more than anything anybody said to her in nine months. She wrote it on an index card and taped it inside her closet door, where it stayed until the day she packed the room under interim suspension, and then she took it down and put it in her wallet, where it still is.

She began keeping records.

Screenshots went into one folder. Dates went into another. Brief notes documented conversations she knew Madison would otherwise describe differently.

The folder was called misc_2, because she was embarrassed by it.

Simone hated doing it because college was supposed to feel freer than high school, not like a place where she needed to prepare evidence against classmates. She hated the way it changed her attention. She would be walking across the quad and something would happen and some part of her brain would immediately begin composing the entry, and that part of her brain was not available for anything else, and she started to notice that she was no longer fully present in her own life.

She told Lena about the folder once, in February, and Lena said, “That’s smart,” and Simone said, “It’s not smart, it’s sad,” and Lena said, “Both.”

The folder would eventually run to sixty-one items.

Eleven of them were screenshots. Four were photographs. Two were voicemails. The rest were notes, typed on her phone, usually within an hour, in a flat declarative style that she had taught herself from reading Ramsey’s field protocols.

Oct 3, approx 1540, outside Hartwell. MV said “there goes the camp counselor” as I passed with the dip net. CB present. One other (male, didn’t know him) present, did not laugh.

Nov 12, lab 204. MV asked if I was “stocking the freezer.” Lena told her it was old. MV said people are too sensitive.

Jan 22, dining hall. MV asked how much Carver pays “if you don’t mind.” I said I did mind. She said “wow, okay.”

By October, the problem moved from comments to interference.

Someone removed Simone’s field notebook from the aquatic lab and left it on a bench beside the lake with a sticky note reading, POND GIRL HQ.

Nothing inside was damaged.

That is also worth sitting with. Nothing inside was damaged, which meant that there was no property crime, which meant that the only harm was the harm of being told, in handwriting, that somebody had gone into the building where you work and taken the object you write in and carried it four hundred yards and left it where you would have to come and get it.

The notebook contained eleven weeks of observations in pencil. It contained the only copy of her November transect data, because she had not yet entered it. It had been sitting on a bench in the open air for somewhere between two and fourteen hours, depending on when it was taken, in a week when it rained twice.

It was dry. Whoever took it had put it under the bench slats, out of the weather.

Simone found that detail more disturbing than if they had thrown it in the lake. It meant care. It meant the person had thought about it and had decided to be cruel precisely and not sloppily.

Professor Ramsey treated the disappearance seriously because the notebook contained research observations. He had a view about field notebooks that his students found slightly unhinged and that he considered the most important thing he taught: that a field notebook is not a personal item, it is a primary record, and that interfering with one is interfering with the scientific record.

He asked who had access to the lab.

Several students did, including Madison, who was taking a separate ecology course using the same building.

No camera covered the equipment room.

Madison denied touching the notebook.

The incident ended without discipline.

Ramsey wrote a memo about it anyway. It was one page. He sent it to the department chair and copied Dean Bell, and it said that an undergraduate research record had been removed from a secured space and relocated in a manner intended to humiliate a specific student, that he could not identify the individual responsible, and that he was documenting the event because he believed it was part of a pattern.

That memo is dated October 19.

It is Exhibit 3.

A week later, Simone discovered that somebody had loosened the drag setting on one of her fishing reels during an angling-club outing.

She noticed because a two-pound bass nearly spooled her. A reel set correctly does not do that. She reeled in, looked at the drag star, and found it backed almost all the way off — not to zero, which would have been obvious the moment she picked it up, but to the edge of useless.

It might have been accidental. Reels get bumped. Bags get jostled. She refused to accuse anyone without evidence, and she said so out loud to Lena, who said, “You are the most annoyingly fair person I have ever met.”

Then Madison walked past and asked whether “grandpa’s fishing stick” was giving her trouble.

Simone had never told Madison the rod belonged to Walter.

She stood on the bank with the rod in her hands and the world went very quiet and very specific, the way it does, and she thought: How do you know that.

News in the same category

They Humiliated Her By The Lake For Laughs — Then The Footage Exposed What Came Before

20 Part