I told him why I had come, and I did not dress it up. I told him about the ditch my grandfather had dug by hand in the nineteen sixties, and about the pipe that ran through my land, and about Karen Whitmore and the Briar Ridge HOA, and about the week my well ran dry and my crops stood dying in the field while the HOA's fountain kept dancing in the sun. I told him about the meeting in the clubhouse, and about the board voting to keep my water, and about the letter I had sent that no one had answered. I told him all of it in the plain language I would have used with any neighbor, and I watched his face as I spoke, and I saw something there that I had not expected to see. I saw recognition.
"Karen Whitmore," he said, and he said her name the way a man says the name of a bad winter, with a kind of weary familiarity. "Yes. I know Karen Whitmore. I have known her for years, and I have been dealing with her for years, and I will tell you something, Mr. Mercer, because you have come all this way and because you deserve to hear it from someone who has been on the other end of that phone. She has been difficult for years. She has been difficult since the day she took over that HOA, and she was difficult before that, when she was only on the board. She calls, and she demands, and she threatens, and she talks about lawyers, and she talks about the county, and she talks about anyone she thinks might frighten a man into doing what she wants."
He leaned back in his chair, and the chair creaked, and he looked out the window for a moment at the parking lot below. "But I kept supplying her," he said. "I kept supplying Briar Ridge, because she paid. That is the truth of it. She paid, and in this business, when someone pays, you keep the water flowing. She was often late, and I mean often late, sometimes weeks late, sometimes more than a month, and I would call, and I would send letters, and eventually a check would arrive, and I would cash it, and I would move on to the next problem. That is how it went, year after year. She paid late, and I kept the water on, because that is what you do when you are running a small cooperative and you cannot afford to lose a customer that big."
I asked him about the pipe, about the pipe that ran through my land, and he nodded slowly, as if he had been waiting for me to ask that question.
"The company owns the pipe," he said. "That much is true. We laid it, we maintain it, we are responsible for it. But the easement, Mr. Mercer, the easement is another matter entirely. The easement that allowed us to run that pipe across your land, that easement is no longer valid. It expired years ago, and nobody ever renewed it, and nobody ever checked. That is the part no one wants to talk about. The pipe kept operating because nobody checked. Nobody looked at the paperwork. Nobody asked the question. It just kept running, year after year, because the water kept flowing and the bills kept getting paid, and in a small operation like this one, when something works, you do not go looking for reasons to stop it."
He stood up then and went to the filing cabinet with the drawer that would not close, and he pulled out a folder that was thick with paper, and he set it on the desk between us, and he opened it, and I saw pages that were yellowed at the edges, and diagrams drawn by hand, and letters typed on a typewriter, and stamps and signatures that belonged to another era. "This is the file on your land," he said. "This is the file on the pipe. I have read it, and I have had my lawyer read it, and I will tell you what it says, because you have a right to know. The easement was granted for a limited time, and that time has passed, and the pipe should have been addressed years ago, and it was not, because no one wanted to be the man who turned off the water."
I sat there in that chair with the spring poking through the seat, and I listened to him, and I felt something shifting inside me, something I had not felt since the morning I found my well dry. It was not anger, exactly, although there was anger in it. It was the feeling of a door opening that I had not known was there. For weeks I had been fighting a woman who seemed to have all the power, a woman with a board behind her and a lawyer behind that, and now I was sitting across from a tired sixty-seven-year-old man in an office above a hardware store, and he was telling me that the whole thing rested on paperwork that had expired years ago, and that nobody had ever bothered to check.